Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 28 of 37 ยท Market Failure and Government

Externalities and Pigouvian Taxes

Learn why markets overproduce goods with external costs and underproduce those with external benefits, and how taxes, subsidies and permits can fix it.

Competitive markets can be remarkably good at allocating resources, but only under conditions. When those fail, the market outcome is not the best for society. This is a market failure. The most common cause is an externality: a cost or benefit that falls on someone who is not part of the transaction.

A factory that pollutes a river, a driver who causes congestion, a neighbor who plants a beautiful garden: in each case a third party is affected, and nobody is paid or charged for it.

Negative and positive externalities

  • A negative externality imposes a cost on others: air pollution, noise, second-hand smoke, traffic jams, antibiotic overuse.
  • A positive externality gives a benefit to others: vaccination (protects others), education, beekeeping near orchards, research that others can build on.

Buyers and sellers consider only their private costs and benefits. Society cares about the social cost and benefit:

social cost = private cost + external cost

social benefit = private benefit + external benefit

A worked example: a polluting factory

Suppose the market for a product has demand P = 80 - Q and private marginal cost (the supply curve) MC = 10 + Q. Producing each unit also creates an external cost of $10 (pollution damage). So the social marginal cost is MSC = 20 + Q.

  • Market outcome: demand equals private supply: 80 - Q = 10 + Q, so Q = 35 and P = 45.
  • Social optimum: demand equals social cost: 80 - Q = 20 + Q, so Q = 30 and the price would be 50.

At Q = 35, the last unit is valued at $45 by consumers, but its true cost to society is 20 + 35 = 55. Producing it destroys $10 of value. The same is true of every unit between 30 and 35, so the deadweight loss is the triangle with base 5 (the extra units) and height 10 (the gap at 35): ยฝ ร— 5 ร— 10 = 25.

Python Market versus social optimum

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Fixing a negative externality

The goal is to make the producer face the full social cost: to internalize the externality.

  1. Pigouvian tax. A tax per unit equal to the external cost (here $10) shifts the producer's cost curve up to the social marginal cost. The market then produces the optimal quantity of 30 on its own. It is named after the economist Arthur Pigou. Carbon taxes and congestion charges follow this idea, and the revenue can be used to reduce other taxes or compensate victims.
  2. Regulation. The government sets a standard (maximum emissions per factory) or bans certain practices. This is simple but inflexible, because every firm must meet the same rule even if some can cut pollution much more cheaply than others.
  3. Tradable permits (cap and trade). The government fixes the total allowed pollution and issues permits that firms can trade. Firms with low abatement costs cut pollution and sell their permits to firms with high costs, so a given reduction is achieved at the lowest total cost.
  4. Property rights and bargaining. The economist Ronald Coase argued that if property rights are clearly assigned and bargaining costs are low, the affected parties can negotiate a good outcome by themselves, whoever holds the right. In practice, with many people involved, this rarely works (try negotiating with every person who breathes the smoke).
Python Tax equal to the external cost

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The new quantity is 30, the socially efficient level. Buyers pay 50 and sellers receive 40.

Positive externalities

A vaccination protects the person vaccinated (private benefit) and others by reducing disease spread (external benefit). Because individuals ignore the external benefit, too few people vaccinate and the market underproduces. The social marginal benefit is above private marginal benefit.

Policy responses: subsidies (free or cheap vaccines, tuition support), public provision, mandates or information campaigns. A subsidy equal to the external benefit per unit moves the market to the efficient quantity.

flowchart LR
    A["Externality"] --> B{"Sign?"}
    B -->|"Negative"| C["Overproduction<br/>tax, regulation, permits"]
    B -->|"Positive"| D["Underproduction<br/>subsidy, public provision"]

Negative externalities cause too much output; positive externalities cause too little.

Limits of the policy tools

  • Measuring the external cost is hard: what is the monetary damage of a ton of carbon dioxide?
  • Taxes can be unpopular and may fall heavily on poorer households.
  • Global externalities such as climate change need international cooperation, with each country tempted to free-ride.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. An externality is

    Third parties bear or enjoy effects that the buyer and seller do not take into account.
  2. 2. With a negative externality, the market quantity compared with the social optimum is

    Producers ignore the external cost, so private marginal cost is below social marginal cost and too much is produced.
  3. 3. A Pigouvian tax should be set equal to

    This makes the producer face the full social cost of each unit.
  4. 4. Which is a positive externality?

    Others benefit without paying: vaccination lowers their chance of infection.

Summary

  • Externalities are spillover costs or benefits on third parties; markets then fail to reach the efficient quantity.
  • Negative externality: overproduction. Positive: underproduction.
  • Tools: Pigouvian taxes and subsidies, regulation, tradable permits and bargaining over property rights.
  • A tax equal to marginal external cost restores the social optimum.

Next: Public Goods and Common Resources