Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 29 of 37 ยท Market Failure and Government

Public Goods and Common Resources

Classify goods by rivalry and excludability, see why free riders block private provision of public goods, and why shared resources get overused.

Most goods are easy to sell: you pay, and you get the good. But some goods are hard to sell because you cannot stop people from using them without paying. Others are free to use but limited, and people exhaust them. These are two more reasons for market failure, and they explain why governments provide street lighting, national defense and clean air policies.

Two properties of goods

  • A good is excludable if people who do not pay can be kept from using it (a cinema ticket, a toll road).
  • A good is rival if one person's use reduces what is left for others (an apple, a parking space).

Combining the two gives four types.

Rival Non-rival
Excludable Private goods: bread, clothes, a sandwich Club goods: streaming service, private park, cable TV
Non-excludable Common resources: fish in the ocean, shared pasture, clean air Public goods: national defense, street lights, weather forecasts

Public goods and the free-rider problem

A pure public good is both non-excludable and non-rival. Once a lighthouse shines, every ship benefits, and one ship using the light leaves just as much for others.

Because people cannot be excluded, each person is tempted to be a free rider: enjoy the good without paying and hope others will pay. If everyone reasons this way, nobody pays, and the market supplies too little or none.

Public goods are valuable, so the efficient quantity is where the sum of everyone's marginal benefits equals the marginal cost. (For private goods, you add quantities across people; for public goods, because all consume the same unit, you add the values across people.)

A worked example: street lights

Three neighbors, A, B and C, value the street's lights. Their marginal willingness to pay (in dollars) for the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, ... light:

Light number A B C Sum
1 10 8 6 24
2 8 6 4 18
3 6 4 2 12
4 4 2 0 6
5 2 0 0 2

Each light costs $10 to provide.

  • Efficient provision: add lights while the sum of benefits is at least the cost. The sum is 24, 18, 12 (all at least 10) and then 6 (less than 10). So 3 lights.
  • Private provision: Neighbor A would pay for a light only if it is worth at least 10 to A. Only the first light qualifies (10). B and C will free-ride on it. So 1 light is provided, below the efficient 3.
Python Efficient versus private provision

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The market fails because each person ignores the benefits their light brings to the neighbors.

Solutions for public goods

  • Government provision financed by taxes. Taxes force everyone to contribute. Examples: defense, the justice system, basic research.
  • Cost-benefit analysis to decide how much to supply (a hard task, because people may hide their true valuation to pay less).
  • Voluntary and community solutions: charity, small groups with social pressure, donor-funded services.
  • Make the good excludable: encrypt a broadcast, build a toll gate, which turns it into a club good.

Common resources and the tragedy of the commons

A common resource is rival but non-excludable: fish in an open ocean, an unfenced pasture, a shared aquifer. Each user takes the whole benefit of using it but shares the damage (depletion) with everyone. This creates overuse: the tragedy of the commons.

A worked example: a lake with fishing boats

The total catch with B boats is C(B) = 40B - 2Bยฒ (fish per day, each worth $1). Each boat costs $12 per day to run. The average catch per boat is 40 - 2B.

  • Open access: boats enter while the average catch exceeds cost: 40 - 2B = 12 gives B = 14. Total catch is 560 - 392 = 168, revenue 168, cost 14 ร— 12 = 168, profit zero.
  • Efficient: the best number maximizes catch value minus cost. The marginal catch of one more boat, 40 - 4B, should equal the cost 12: B = 7. Then C(7) = 280 - 98 = 182, costs are 7 ร— 12 = 84, and profit is 182 - 84 = 98.
Python Open-access fishing versus the efficient number of boats

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Open access ends with twice the efficient number of boats and zero profit: effort is wasted, and in real fisheries the fish stock can collapse.

Solutions for common resources

  • Property rights: assign ownership (private or communal) so the owner has an interest in sustainability.
  • Quotas and licenses: limit the total catch or number of boats; tradable quotas let efficient operators buy from others.
  • Taxes or fees on use (for example a charge for entering a congested city center).
  • Community management: the economist Elinor Ostrom showed that many local communities manage shared resources successfully with clear boundaries, rules and monitoring.

Many modern examples combine these ideas: overfishing, groundwater depletion, congestion on free roads, and the global atmosphere as a dumping ground for carbon dioxide.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A good that is non-excludable and non-rival is a

    Nobody can be excluded and one person's use does not reduce availability for others.
  2. 2. The free-rider problem arises because

    If you cannot be excluded, you have an incentive to let others pay.
  3. 3. The efficient quantity of a public good is where

    All consumers share each unit, so we add their marginal benefits vertically.
  4. 4. The tragedy of the commons describes

    Each user ignores the damage their use does to others, so the resource is overused.

Summary

  • Goods differ by excludability and rivalry: private, club, common and public goods.
  • Public goods suffer from free riding, so markets underprovide them; add benefits vertically to find the efficient amount.
  • Common resources are overused because users ignore the cost they impose on others.
  • Solutions: taxes and public provision, property rights, quotas, fees and community rules.

Next: Price Controls and Taxes