Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 3 of 37 ยท Getting Started

Positive and Normative Statements

Learn to tell facts from opinions in economics: positive statements can be tested with evidence, normative statements rest on values. Practice with examples.

Arguments about economics often mix two kinds of claims without saying so. Someone says "the minimum wage should be raised" as if it were a fact, while someone else replies with a statistic. They talk past each other because one is stating a value and the other is stating evidence. Economists separate these two kinds of statements, and learning to do the same makes you a sharper reader of news.

Positive statements

A positive statement describes what is, was or will be. It is about facts and cause and effect. The key feature is that it can be tested against evidence. A positive statement can still be wrong; what matters is that evidence could show whether it is right or wrong.

Examples:

  • "When the price of a ticket rises from 8 to 10 dollars, the number of tickets sold falls."
  • "The unemployment rate in the town was 6% last year."
  • "A tax on cigarettes reduces the number of cigarettes sold."

The second statement is probably checkable against official records. The first and third can be checked by looking at data from many markets. If the data contradicts them, the statements are wrong, but they are still positive.

Normative statements

A normative statement says what ought to be. It contains a value judgment, such as an opinion about what is fair, good or desirable. No evidence alone can prove it true or false, because people can reasonably hold different values.

Examples:

  • "The government should raise taxes on cigarettes."
  • "Rich people ought to pay more tax."
  • "It is unfair that rents are so high."

Key words often give normative statements away: should, ought, fair, unfair, better, worse, good, bad. But be careful, because words alone are not a perfect test. "A fair price is one at which supply equals demand" is a definition, while "this price is unfair" is a value claim.

How to tell them apart

Ask: could I settle this with data, in principle?

Statement Type Why
Inflation was 3% last year. Positive A measurable fact.
Inflation is too high. Normative "Too high" depends on values.
Raising the minimum wage reduces jobs for young workers. Positive Can be tested, even if hard.
The minimum wage should be raised. Normative Depends on what you value.
Taxes on fuel will cut fuel use by 5%. Positive A forecast that can be checked.

A statement can also be positive and false. "The moon is made of cheese" is positive and false. Positive does not mean true.

JS Positive or normative?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

This is only a rule of thumb based on clue words, and it can be fooled. Add "A fair share is half" to see where it gets confused. The best test is still the question: could evidence settle it?

Why the difference matters in policy

Most real debates have both parts. Take the question "Should the city limit rents?"

  1. Positive part: What happens to the number of apartments, the quality of housing and who finds a home if rents are limited? Evidence and models can help.
  2. Normative part: How much weight should we give to current tenants versus future tenants, or to fairness versus efficiency? That is a matter of values.

Economists can improve the positive part: they can predict outcomes and measure costs. They cannot, as economists, tell you which values to hold. When you hear an argument, split it into these two parts and ask whether people disagree about the facts, the values, or both.

Do not assume that a normative claim is "just an opinion" and therefore unimportant. Values drive most decisions. The point is only to know which kind of claim you are arguing about.

Disagreement among economists

Economists disagree for two reasons. Some disagreements are about positive questions: different models or data lead to different predictions. Others are normative: different values about equality, freedom or risk. Surveys of economists often show broad agreement on some positive claims (for example, that trade between countries raises total output) while disagreeing on policies, because policies depend on values as well.

A tool to sort sentences

This program stores a list with hand-labelled sentences and checks your own label against it, like a tiny practice quiz.

Python Practice labelling

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Change the list my_answers and rerun to see how the score changes.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which is a positive statement?

    It describes cause and effect that can be checked with data. The others contain value judgments.
  2. 2. A positive statement must always be

    Positive statements can be wrong; what makes them positive is that evidence could test them.
  3. 3. Which words often signal a normative statement?

    Words like should, ought and unfair express value judgments.
  4. 4. Two people disagree about whether a tax should exist. One cites a study; the other talks about fairness. What is happening?

    The study speaks to the positive part and fairness to the normative part, so the debate mixes both.

Summary

  • Positive statements describe what is and can be tested with evidence; they can still be false.
  • Normative statements say what ought to be and rest on values.
  • Words such as should, ought and fair are clues, but the real test is whether evidence could settle the claim.
  • Policy debates usually combine both kinds of claim, so separate them before arguing.

Next: Economic Models and Assumptions