Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 33 of 37 ยท Labor Markets and Distribution

Wage Differences and the Minimum Wage

Why a surgeon earns more than a cashier: human capital, compensating differentials and discrimination, plus minimum wage effects in competitive and monopsony markets.

In the same economy, one person earns ten times what another does. Some differences feel fair, some do not, and economics offers explanations for each. This lesson covers the main reasons wages differ and then examines one of the most debated policies in economics: the minimum wage.

Why wages differ

  1. Human capital. Education, training and experience raise a worker's productivity. A surgeon spends many years studying (and gives up earnings while studying), and her marginal revenue product is high, so employers pay more. The extra income is partly a return on that investment.
  2. Compensating differentials. Jobs that are dangerous, unpleasant or irregular must pay more to attract workers: offshore drilling, night shifts, remote postings. Jobs with attractive features (a pleasant location, high prestige) can pay less.
  3. Scarcity of skills. If few people can do a job and many firms want them, supply is small relative to demand and the wage is high. Professional athletes and top programmers are examples.
  4. Superstar effects. When a performer can serve a huge market at almost no extra cost (a singer recorded once for millions of listeners), small differences in talent translate into large differences in income.
  5. Unions and bargaining power. Unions may raise wages for their members, sometimes at the expense of non-members or employment.
  6. Efficiency wages. Some firms pay above the market wage to reduce turnover, attract better candidates or motivate effort.
  7. Discrimination. Treating workers differently because of gender, race, ethnicity or other characteristics unrelated to productivity lowers wages and job opportunities for some groups. It is both unfair and inefficient, since talent is wasted. Measuring it is hard, because other legitimate factors differ too; researchers compare people with similar qualifications.
Python Return on education: a simple present-value comparison

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The model treats education as an investment: people compare the present value of extra earnings with the cost. Real choices also depend on interests, risk and unpaid benefits.

Minimum wage in the competitive model

A minimum wage is a legal wage floor. In the standard competitive model, if it is set above the equilibrium wage, it creates a surplus of labor, that is, unemployment.

Use the market from the previous lesson: Ld = 100 - 5W, Ls = 20 + 3W. Equilibrium is W = 10, L = 50. If the minimum wage is $12:

  • Employers demand 100 - 60 = 40.
  • Workers want to supply 20 + 36 = 56.
  • Unemployment: 56 - 40 = 16.

Workers who keep their jobs gain; those who lose jobs or cannot find them lose. A minimum wage below $10 would have no effect.

Minimum wage with monopsony power

A monopsony is a market with a single (or dominant) buyer of labor, for example the only large employer in a small town. A firm like that has to raise the wage for all workers to hire one more, so the marginal cost of labor (MFC) exceeds the wage and the firm hires fewer workers at lower wages than a competitive market.

Let the supply be W = 5 + 0.2L (L in thousands) and the marginal revenue product MRP = 25 - 0.2L.

  • Competitive outcome: W = MRP: 5 + 0.2L = 25 - 0.2L, so L = 50, W = 15.
  • Monopsony: the total labor cost is W ร— L = 5L + 0.2Lยฒ, so the marginal cost of labor is MFC = 5 + 0.4L. The firm hires where MFC = MRP: 5 + 0.4L = 25 - 0.2L, so 0.6L = 20, L = 33.3, and the wage is 5 + 0.2 ร— 33.3 = 11.67.

Now impose a minimum wage of $13. The firm can no longer pay less than 13, so the extra cost of an additional worker is simply 13 until supply is exhausted. Workers willing to work at $13: L = (13 - 5) / 0.2 = 40. The MRP at 40 is 25 - 8 = 17, above 13, so the firm hires all 40. Employment rises from 33.3 to 40 and the wage rises from 11.67 to 13. A minimum wage at the competitive level of $15 would lead to 50 workers.

Python Minimum wage under competition and monopsony

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Employment rises as the floor goes up from 11.67 to 15, peaking at the competitive wage of $15. Above $15, workers are plentiful but the firm hires only while MRP covers the wage: at $18 only 35 thousand are hired. Try more values to see this hump-shaped pattern.

What does evidence say?

Empirical research is mixed. Studies of modest increases often find small or no job losses, which is consistent with employers having some monopsony power, adjusting prices and hours, or reducing turnover. Very high minimum wages relative to local wages are more likely to cost jobs, especially for young or low-skilled workers. The effect depends on how high the minimum is compared with typical wages, and on the local labor market.

Other policies can raise low incomes: wage subsidies and earned-income tax credits, training programs, and cash transfers. Each has costs and trade-offs.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A job that is dangerous or unpleasant tends to pay more. This is called a

    Higher pay compensates workers for the unattractive features of the job.
  2. 2. In the competitive model, a minimum wage above the equilibrium wage causes

    More people want to work at the high wage than firms want to hire.
  3. 3. A monopsonist compared with a competitive employer hires

    To hire one more worker it must raise the wage for everyone, so it restricts hiring and pays less.
  4. 4. Which is NOT a standard explanation for wage differences?

    The paper color has no economic influence on productivity or job conditions.

Summary

  • Wages differ because of human capital, job conditions, skill scarcity, bargaining power, efficiency wages and discrimination.
  • A minimum wage above equilibrium in a competitive market creates unemployment.
  • If employers have monopsony power, a moderate minimum wage can raise both wages and employment.
  • Evidence is mixed and depends on the level of the minimum relative to local wages.

Next: Income Inequality and Poverty