Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 23 of 37 ยท Consumers and Producers

Long-Run Costs and Economies of Scale

See how firms choose plant size in the long run, why larger scale can lower unit costs, and where diseconomies of scale and minimum efficient scale come in.

In the short run a firm is stuck with its factory. In the long run it can choose a different size: a bigger plant, a second shift of machines, another city. The question becomes: what is the cheapest way to produce each level of output when everything can be adjusted?

The answer is the long-run average cost (LRAC) curve, and its shape explains why some industries have giants and others have thousands of small firms.

Many short-run curves, one long-run curve

Each possible plant size has its own short-run ATC curve, U-shaped because of diminishing returns to the fixed plant. For any planned output, the firm picks the plant with the lowest cost. The LRAC curve is the lower envelope of all the short-run curves: the cheapest cost achievable at each output once the plant can be chosen freely.

Python Three plant sizes and their envelope

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The figures are an invented illustration. Each plant has a low point of its own ATC; larger plants have bigger fixed costs but a smaller increase in cost per extra unit. At small outputs the small plant is cheapest. At moderate outputs the medium plant wins. The large plant is cheapest only when output is high.

Economies, constant returns and diseconomies of scale

How LRAC changes as the firm grows:

  • Economies of scale: LRAC falls as output rises. Doubling all inputs more than doubles output.
  • Constant returns to scale: LRAC is flat. Doubling inputs doubles output.
  • Diseconomies of scale: LRAC rises. Doubling inputs less than doubles output.

In the example above, the minimum ATC drops from about 20 (small plant) to about 12.65 (medium) and then rises to about 17.9 (large). So the firm has economies of scale up to a medium plant and diseconomies after that.

flowchart LR
    A["Small plant<br/>high cost per unit"] --> B["Economies of scale<br/>LRAC falls"]
    B --> C["Minimum efficient scale<br/>LRAC at its lowest"]
    C --> D["Diseconomies of scale<br/>LRAC rises"]

The long-run average cost curve passes through three phases as output grows.

Why scale lowers costs

  1. Specialization. Bigger firms can divide jobs: one team handles design, another sales, another repairs.
  2. Spreading fixed costs. A single research lab, a brand name or a delivery fleet is spread over more units.
  3. Bulk buying. Large orders earn discounts from suppliers.
  4. Better technology. Some methods only pay off at large volumes: an assembly line, a blast furnace, a fiber-optic network.
  5. Cheaper finance. Big, established firms often borrow at lower interest rates.

Why scale can raise costs

  1. Coordination problems. Many layers of managers slow decisions.
  2. Communication and motivation. Workers in huge organizations may feel less responsible for results.
  3. Limits of the market or input supply. To expand a mine or farm further, a firm may have to use poorer land or pay higher prices for scarce inputs.

Minimum efficient scale and market structure

The minimum efficient scale (MES) is the smallest output at which the firm reaches the lowest LRAC. Compare MES with the size of the market:

  • If MES is small compared with market demand, many firms can each reach MES: the market can be competitive (for example, bakeries).
  • If MES is a large share of demand, only one or a few firms can be efficient. This suggests a natural monopoly (electric grids, water pipes, railways) or an oligopoly (aircraft manufacturing).

This link from cost structure to market structure is the starting point of our chapter on market structures.

Python How many firms can the market support?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

External economies of scale

Sometimes costs fall because the industry grows, not the firm. When many software companies cluster in one region, they share a pool of skilled workers, specialist suppliers and university research. Each firm stays small but benefits from the size of the cluster. These are external economies of scale; the earlier ones are internal.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. The long-run average cost curve is

    In the long run the firm can pick the best plant for each output, so LRAC follows the lowest points available from all short-run curves.
  2. 2. Doubling all inputs yields more than double the output. This is

    Output grows faster than inputs, so average cost falls: economies of scale.
  3. 3. Which is a cause of diseconomies of scale?

    Very large firms can suffer from slow decisions and poor communication that raise unit costs.
  4. 4. If the minimum efficient scale is almost as large as the whole market, we expect

    Only one or a few firms can reach the lowest cost, so the market tends toward natural monopoly or oligopoly.

Summary

  • In the long run all inputs are flexible; LRAC is the lower envelope of short-run ATC curves.
  • Economies of scale: falling LRAC. Constant returns: flat. Diseconomies: rising LRAC.
  • Causes of economies: specialization, spreading fixed costs, bulk buying, technology, cheaper finance.
  • Minimum efficient scale compared with market size helps explain market structure.
  • External economies come from the size of the industry, not the firm.

Next: Perfect Competition