Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 28 of 37 ยท International Organizations

The General Assembly and the Security Council

Compare the UN General Assembly and Security Council: who sits in each, how votes work, what the veto means and why reform is debated.

Of the six main organs of the United Nations, two do most of the work that makes headlines: the General Assembly, where every country has a seat, and the Security Council, where a handful of countries hold special power. They were designed to balance two ideas that pull in opposite directions: equality among all states, and the reality that some states can act with far more force than others.

The General Assembly

The General Assembly is the UN's "world parliament", though it cannot pass laws.

  • Members: all 193 member states, each with one vote, no matter the size or wealth of the country.
  • Meets: a regular session opens each September in New York, with a general debate where leaders and ministers speak. Special sessions can be called.
  • Decisions: ordinary matters need a simple majority of those voting. "Important questions", such as peace and security recommendations, admitting new members and electing members of some bodies, need a two-thirds majority.
  • Powers: it discusses any matter within the Charter, approves the UN budget, elects the non-permanent members of the Security Council and appoints the Secretary-General on the Council's recommendation.
  • Weakness: its resolutions are generally recommendations, not binding on states. They carry moral and political weight, and they often shape international law over time, but they cannot force anyone.

Most of the General Assembly's detailed work is done in six main committees, where every member can take part.

The Security Council

The Security Council has "primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security". Unlike the Assembly, its decisions can be legally binding on all UN members, especially when it acts under Chapter VII of the Charter, which covers threats to the peace, breaches of the peace and acts of aggression. It can impose sanctions, authorize peacekeeping missions and, in the last resort, authorize the use of force.

Membership

There are 15 members:

  • Five permanent members (the P5): China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States. They were the main victorious powers of the Second World War.
  • Ten non-permanent members, elected by the General Assembly for two-year terms, five each year, chosen with attention to regional balance. They cannot be re-elected immediately.

The Council grew from 11 to 15 members in 1965. The permanent membership has not changed in its list of five since the UN's founding, apart from the seat's holders changing: China's seat passed to the People's Republic of China in 1971, and Russia took the Soviet Union's seat after 1991.

The presidency rotates monthly among the members in English alphabetical order.

Voting and the veto

A substantive decision needs at least nine votes in favor, and no permanent member voting against. A "no" vote by any of the P5 is called a veto and blocks the resolution, even if 14 members support it. An abstention is not a veto: a resolution can pass if a permanent member abstains.

flowchart TD
  A["Draft resolution"] --> B{"At least 9 votes in favor?"}
  B -- No --> X["Not adopted"]
  B -- Yes --> C{"Any permanent member votes against?"}
  C -- Yes --> V["Vetoed: not adopted"]
  C -- No --> OK["Adopted"]

Abstentions by permanent members do not block a resolution. Procedural questions need nine votes without a veto.

The veto was built in so that the great powers would join and stay in the UN, and so that the UN would not take enforcement action against one of them. The cost is that the Council may be unable to act on crises that involve a permanent member or its allies. Critics call this a serious flaw; defenders argue that a council that could be used against a major power could not work.

When the Council is stuck

In 1950 the General Assembly adopted the "Uniting for Peace" resolution, which allows it to take up a matter of international peace when the Security Council fails to act because of a veto. The Assembly can then recommend collective measures, but it cannot order them. In recent years the Assembly has also begun to hold a debate whenever a veto is cast.

Reform

The Council's membership reflects the world of 1945. Many states say it should include more members from Africa, Asia and Latin America, and that the veto should be limited. Proposals differ on whether to add permanent seats, longer-term seats or both. Reform needs the agreement of two-thirds of the General Assembly and ratification by two-thirds of members, including all five permanent members, so change has been slow.

Try it: simulate a Security Council vote

This program is a stand-in for the voting rule described above. Change the votes and see whether the resolution passes.

JS Does the resolution pass?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The second example shows the General Assembly's two-thirds rule on important questions.

JS Two-thirds majority

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. How many votes does each member have in the General Assembly?

    The Assembly is based on sovereign equality: one state, one vote.
  2. 2. How many members does the Security Council have?

    Five permanent plus ten elected non-permanent members make fifteen.
  3. 3. A resolution has 13 votes in favor and one permanent member votes no. What happens?

    A negative vote by any permanent member blocks substantive resolutions, whatever the other votes.
  4. 4. What does an abstention by a permanent member do?

    Only a 'no' vote is a veto. An abstention allows the resolution to pass.

Summary

  • The General Assembly has all 193 members, one vote each; its resolutions are mostly recommendations.
  • The Security Council has 15 members: five permanent (China, France, Russia, UK, US) and ten elected for two years.
  • Decisions need nine votes and no veto from a permanent member; binding decisions can include sanctions and authorized force.
  • The veto can block action; the Assembly can discuss matters when the Council is deadlocked.
  • Reform is debated but needs the agreement of the permanent members.

Next: Regional Organizations