Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 9 of 37 Β· Government and Power

Federal and Unitary Governments

Compare federal and unitary governments, learn how power is divided between national and regional levels, and see examples, pros and cons of each design.

Countries need to decide how much power sits at the center and how much stays with regions. Two main designs answer the question. In a unitary state the central government holds the ultimate authority. In a federal state the constitution divides power between the national government and regional governments, so each has areas where it is supreme.

Unitary states

In a unitary state there is one sovereign government. It may create regional or local governments and give them tasks, but it can also change or abolish them through ordinary law. When real powers are passed down but remain revocable in principle, this is called devolution.

Examples include France, Japan and Sweden. The United Kingdom is unitary in law, yet has devolved parliaments or assemblies in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland with real powers over areas such as health and education.

Federal states

In a federal state, power is split by the constitution. Regional governments, often called states, provinces, cantons or LΓ€nder, have their own legislature and executive and their own protected areas of responsibility. Neither level can simply abolish the other. Typically a constitutional court settles disputes about who may do what.

Examples include the United States, Canada, Germany, India, Australia, Brazil, Nigeria and Switzerland. Federations differ a great deal: in some the regions are strong, in others the center dominates.

Feature Unitary Federal
Source of regional power Delegated by the center Guaranteed by the constitution
Can the center abolish regions? Usually yes, by ordinary law Not without constitutional change
Governments with law-making power One main Two or more levels
Examples France, Japan, Sweden United States, Germany, India

A third pattern is the confederation, a loose union of independent states that keeps most power for themselves and gives the central body limited tasks. True confederations are rare today.

How federations divide powers

Constitutions often list responsibilities in three groups.

  • Exclusive national powers, such as defense, currency and foreign affairs.
  • Exclusive regional powers, such as some policing, local roads or education, depending on the country.
  • Shared (concurrent) powers, where both levels may act, such as taxation or environmental rules. If laws conflict, the constitution usually says which prevails.

The constitution also states who holds the residual powers, the matters not listed anywhere. In some federations these go to the regions, in others to the national government.

flowchart TD
    C["Constitution"] --> N["National government<br/>defense, currency, foreign affairs"]
    C --> R["Regional governments<br/>areas set by constitution"]
    N <-->|"shared powers"| R
    CC["Constitutional court"] -->|"settles disputes"| N
    CC -->|"settles disputes"| R

Federalism in a simple picture. Each federation draws the lines differently.

Arguments for and against federalism

Possible benefits

  • Regions can adapt policies to local needs and cultures.
  • Large or diverse countries may stay united while keeping regional identity.
  • Regions can try different ideas, and others can learn from the results.
  • Power is spread, which can limit abuse.

Possible costs

  • Rules and services may differ between regions, which some see as unfair.
  • Overlapping powers can cause delay and blame-shifting.
  • Running two or more levels of government costs money.

Neither design is automatically better. Many small or fairly uniform countries do well as unitary states, while large and diverse countries often choose federalism.

Do not confuse "federal" with "big government". Federalism is about how power is divided, not how much government does. A federal country can have a small state or a large one.

JS Who has the power to do this?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Counting levels in example systems

JS Count levels in made-up systems

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. What is the key difference between federal and unitary states?

    Federal powers are constitutionally divided. Unitary states can create, change or abolish lower levels by law.
  2. 2. Which country is a federation?

    Germany is a federation of LΓ€nder. France and Japan are unitary states.
  3. 3. What are concurrent powers?

    Concurrent (shared) powers can be used by both levels, with rules for conflicts.
  4. 4. What does devolution mean?

    Devolution gives lower levels real powers while the center keeps ultimate authority.

Summary

  • Unitary states hold ultimate authority at the center; federal states divide power by constitution.
  • Federations list national, regional and shared powers and use a court to settle disputes.
  • Devolution passes powers down in a unitary state without guaranteeing them forever.
  • Federalism can suit diverse or large countries but adds complexity and cost.

Next: What Is a Constitution?