Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 13 of 37 ยท Constitutions and Law

Changing a Constitution

Learn how constitutions are amended, why many require supermajorities or referendums, and how courts and custom change constitutions without formal amendments.

A constitution must be stable enough to protect rights and institutions, but flexible enough to adapt to new times. Too easy to change, and a temporary majority could rewrite the rules in its own favor. Too hard to change, and outdated rules may persist for generations. Different countries strike this balance in different ways.

Formal amendment

An amendment is a deliberate change to the written constitution that follows the procedure the constitution itself lays down. Typical methods are:

Method How it works Examples
Legislative supermajority A larger majority than for ordinary law, such as two-thirds, in the legislature Many countries
Approval by regions Federal states require regional governments to agree United States (three-quarters of the states must ratify)
Referendum Voters approve the change in a direct vote Switzerland, Ireland, Australia
Special convention An assembly elected or convened for the purpose Proposed in some constitutions

Switzerland requires a vote of the people and of the cantons for constitutional changes. Australia requires a majority of voters nationwide and a majority of voters in a majority of states. Ireland requires a referendum for amendments. The United States needs a proposal by two-thirds of both houses of Congress (or a convention called by two-thirds of the states) and ratification by three-quarters of the states. These rules are deliberately demanding.

flowchart TD
    P["Proposal"] --> L["Legislature supermajority"]
    L --> R{"Referendum or regional approval needed?"}
    R -->|"Yes"| V["Voters or regions approve"]
    R -->|"No"| A["Amendment adopted"]
    V --> A

One common model of amendment. Each country sets its own steps.

JS Does the amendment pass?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The first line fails in the legislature, the second fails at the regional stage, and only the third meets both thresholds.

Why make it difficult?

  • It protects basic rights from sudden political winds.
  • It forces broad agreement, not just a narrow majority.
  • It encourages careful drafting and public debate.
  • It signals that a constitution is more than an ordinary law.

The trade-off is that some problems may take a long time to solve. Constitutions that are very hard to amend may rely more on courts and interpretation to adapt.

Change without amendment

Constitutions also change in ways that do not alter a word of the text.

  1. Judicial interpretation. Courts apply old words to new situations, such as modern technology. Over decades this can shift the meaning of provisions.
  2. Statutes. Ordinary laws can fill in details, for example how elections are run.
  3. Conventions. Unwritten political customs shape behavior. In the United Kingdom, for example, the monarch by convention acts on ministers' advice.
  4. Practice. Institutions evolve as officials use their powers differently.

Critics worry that when judges change meaning, voters may lose control. Supporters reply that language must be applied to unforeseen problems and that courts must give reasons that others can challenge. Both views are held by serious people, so you should be able to explain each.

Replacing a constitution

Sometimes a country writes an entirely new constitution, for example after independence, a civil war, the collapse of a regime or a big political change. A constituent assembly may draft the text and a referendum may approve it. A new constitution is a chance to reset the rules, but the process can be tense and requires wide acceptance to become legitimate.

Be careful of "constitutional manipulation": changing term limits, court size or election rules mainly to benefit those in power. Formal procedures do not guarantee that a change is fair. Look at who benefits, how open the debate was and whether the public and courts could examine it.

Referendums in brief

A referendum asks voters to decide a specific question directly. A mandatory referendum is required by the constitution for certain changes. An optional one is called by the government or by citizens. Advantages are direct participation and legitimacy. Risks include oversimplifying complex issues, low turnout and heated campaigns. Clear question wording matters, because wording can influence answers.

JS Double majority test for a referendum

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Why do many constitutions require a supermajority to be amended?

    Higher thresholds force broad agreement and protect rights and institutions from short-term changes.
  2. 2. Which of these is a way a constitution can change without altering its text?

    Courts' interpretations, statutes, conventions and practice can shift how a constitution works.
  3. 3. What is a mandatory referendum?

    Some constitutions require voters to approve particular changes.
  4. 4. What risk does constitutional manipulation describe?

    Even formal changes can be abused, for example by removing term limits to stay in power.

Summary

  • Constitutions balance stability with the need to adapt.
  • Amendments often need supermajorities, regional approval or referendums.
  • Constitutions also change through court interpretation, statutes, conventions and practice.
  • Entire new constitutions can be written, usually after major political change.
  • Watch for manipulation aimed at entrenching power.

Next: What Is Democracy?