Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 16 of 37 ยท Democracy and Elections

Electoral Systems

Compare electoral systems: first-past-the-post, two-round runoffs, ranked-choice and proportional representation, with a runnable d'Hondt seat calculator.

An electoral system is the set of rules that turns votes into seats or offices. Two countries can have identical votes and get different winners because they use different rules. Choosing a system is therefore one of the most important design decisions in a democracy.

Plurality, or first-past-the-post

In first-past-the-post (FPTP) the country is divided into districts. Each district elects one member. The candidate with the most votes wins, even without a majority. Used for national legislatures in the United Kingdom, Canada, India and the United States (for most legislative seats).

  • Strengths: simple, a direct link between a member and a district, often produces a clear single-party government.
  • Weaknesses: many votes do not affect the result, and a party can win more seats than its vote share justifies. Smaller parties spread across the country can be underrepresented.

Majority systems

Some systems require the winner to get more than half of the votes.

  • Two-round (runoff): if nobody wins an absolute majority in round one, the top candidates face each other in a second round. Used for presidential elections in France and many other countries.
  • Ranked-choice or instant-runoff: voters rank candidates in order. The candidate with the fewest first preferences is eliminated, and those votes move to the next choices until someone has a majority. Used for some elections in Australia, Ireland (for single-seat contests), and some US cities and states.

Proportional representation (PR)

In PR systems, parties receive seats roughly in proportion to their share of the vote. Usually voters choose in multi-member districts or on national lists. Used for national parliaments in countries such as Sweden, the Netherlands, Spain and many others.

  • Strengths: fewer wasted votes, wider range of voices, parties' seat shares match their support.
  • Weaknesses: more parties often means coalitions, which can take time to form. Closed lists give party leaders power over who gets a seat.

Many countries use a mixed system, combining district seats with list seats, as in Germany and New Zealand.

System Winner decided by Typical result
FPTP Most votes in a district Two main parties, single-party government
Two-round Majority, with a runoff Broad support for the winner
Ranked-choice Eliminations until majority Reduces vote splitting
Proportional Seats shared by vote share Multiparty parliaments, coalitions
Mixed District plus list Combination

A proportional method: d'Hondt

There are several formulas to convert votes into seats. One widely used is the d'Hondt method. You divide each party's votes by 1, 2, 3, and so on, then give seats to the largest quotients, one by one, until all seats are filled.

JS d'Hondt seat calculator

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

FPTP versus PR with the same votes

Imagine three districts with 100 voters each. Party A wins narrowly in all three. Under FPTP, Party A takes all 3 seats. Under PR, seats would be shared by vote share.

JS Same votes, different systems

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The example is invented to show how FPTP can award all seats to a party that wins with less than half of the votes.

No electoral system is perfect. Each trades off simplicity, local representation, fairness to small parties and clear accountability. When you compare systems, ask which of those goals the designers valued most.

Other design choices

  • District size: how many members each district elects.
  • Thresholds: a minimum vote share, such as 5 percent, to win list seats, used to prevent very small parties.
  • Open or closed lists: whether voters can choose individual candidates or only the party.
  • Gerrymandering: drawing district boundaries to favor one party. Independent commissions, fair rules and court review can reduce it.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. In first-past-the-post, who wins a district?

    FPTP is a plurality system: the highest vote count wins, even without a majority.
  2. 2. What is the main idea of proportional representation?

    PR aims to match seat shares to vote shares.
  3. 3. What does a ranked-choice ballot let a voter do?

    Votes transfer to lower preferences when a candidate is eliminated, until someone has a majority.
  4. 4. What is gerrymandering?

    Manipulating boundaries can change outcomes without changing votes.

Summary

  • Electoral systems convert votes into seats; the rules shape the result.
  • FPTP is simple but can leave many votes without influence; majority systems require over half; PR matches seats to vote shares; mixed systems combine them.
  • The d'Hondt method assigns seats by successive highest quotients.
  • Design choices such as thresholds, list type and district boundaries matter.

Next: Political Parties