Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 25 of 37 Β· Political Systems Compared

Federal and Unitary States

Learn how countries divide power between national and regional governments: federal, unitary and devolved models, with examples and trade-offs.

A country is not just one government in one capital. Most states also have regional and local governments, and a key design question is how much power each level holds. Does the national government decide everything and delegate what it likes? Or do regions have their own protected powers that the center cannot remove?

The answer separates unitary states from federal states. This is a different question from presidential versus parliamentary: a federal country can be either, as you saw in the last lesson.

Unitary states

In a unitary state the national government holds the ultimate authority. Regional and local governments may exist, but they get their powers from the national government, which can change or take them back by ordinary law.

Examples: France, Japan, Sweden, Italy and China.

Advantages:

  • Simple, uniform laws and services across the whole country.
  • Quick, centralized decisions.
  • Often cheaper, because there are fewer layers.

Disadvantages:

  • Distant decision-makers may not understand local needs.
  • Regional minorities may feel overlooked.

Devolution

Some unitary states choose to devolve powers: the center passes certain tasks to regional bodies. The United Kingdom has devolved governments for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, with different powers in each. Because the UK Parliament remains legally supreme, it is still counted as unitary, even though devolved powers are politically hard to remove.

Federal states

In a federation the constitution divides power between a national (federal) government and regional governments, often called states, provinces, cantons or LΓ€nder. Each level has its own areas of authority, and neither can simply abolish the other.

Examples:

Country Regional units
United States 50 states
Germany 16 LΓ€nder
India 28 states and 8 union territories
Brazil 26 states and a federal district
Nigeria 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory
Australia 6 states and 2 mainland territories
Canada 10 provinces and 3 territories
Switzerland 26 cantons

Typical federal features:

  • A written constitution that lists which level does what.
  • A court (often a constitutional or supreme court) that settles disputes between levels.
  • Regional representation in the national legislature: many federations have an upper house that speaks for the regions, such as the US Senate or the German Bundesrat.
  • Shared and separate powers. Defense and foreign policy are usually federal. Education, policing, roads or health may be regional, or shared. The exact split differs from country to country.

Advantages:

  • Local decisions can fit local needs, and regions can try different policies.
  • Power is spread out, which can guard against a single concentrated authority.
  • It suits large or diverse countries with distinct languages or regions, as in India, Switzerland and Canada.

Disadvantages:

  • Rules can differ between regions, which can confuse and cause unequal treatment.
  • Overlapping responsibilities can lead to disputes or buck-passing.
  • More levels can mean more cost.

Subsidiarity

A helpful idea in federal thinking is subsidiarity: decisions should be taken at the lowest level that can handle them well. A town decides where to put a playground; a national government handles a national army. The European Union also uses this principle for deciding between EU and national action.

flowchart TD
  F["Federal government<br/>defense, currency, foreign policy"] --> R1["Region A government"]
  F --> R2["Region B government"]
  R1 --> L1["Local councils"]
  R2 --> L2["Local councils"]
  C["Constitution + constitutional court"] -.-> F
  C -.-> R1
  C -.-> R2

In a federation the constitution protects each level's powers. In a unitary state the arrows from the top would be lines of delegation that the center can change.

Confederations

A confederation is a looser union where independent states keep most power and the central body is weak. The early United States under the Articles of Confederation (before the 1787 Constitution) was one. True confederations are rare today.

Try it: who decides?

This program is a stand-in for a constitution's list of powers. Edit the table to see how the answer depends on the system. The allocation shown is typical, not a statement about any one country.

JS Who has the power?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

This second example counts how many regional units each of several federations has and the average share per unit. The unit counts come from the table above.

JS Regions per federation

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. In a unitary state, where does ultimate authority lie?

    Regional bodies in a unitary state hold only the powers the national government gives them.
  2. 2. Which country is a federation?

    Germany has 16 LΓ€nder with their own protected powers. France and Japan are unitary.
  3. 3. What is subsidiarity?

    Subsidiarity keeps decisions as close to the people affected as is sensible.
  4. 4. Why can the United Kingdom still be called unitary despite devolution?

    Devolved bodies exist, but the national Parliament holds the ultimate legal authority.

Summary

  • Unitary states keep ultimate power at the center; regional bodies hold delegated powers.
  • Federations divide power in a constitution, so each level has protected authority and a court settles disputes.
  • Devolution shifts powers to regions inside a unitary state.
  • Federal and unitary designs both have trade-offs between uniformity, local fit and cost.
  • Subsidiarity says to decide at the lowest suitable level.

Next: Monarchies and Republics