Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 26 of 37 ยท Political Systems Compared

Monarchies and Republics

Learn how monarchies and republics differ, what a head of state does, and why 'republic' does not automatically mean 'democracy'. Examples and quiz.

Every country needs someone, or something, to stand as its head of state: the symbol of the nation and its highest formal representative. How a country chooses this person divides the world into monarchies and republics.

This lesson separates three roles that people often blur together: head of state, head of government and the real source of power. Once you see them apart, labels such as "constitutional monarchy" and "ceremonial president" become easy.

Head of state versus head of government

Role What it does Example titles
Head of state Represents the country, signs laws, receives ambassadors, awards honors King, queen, emperor, president
Head of government Leads the cabinet and directs the daily work of government Prime minister, chancellor, president

In some countries one person holds both roles (the United States has a president who is both). In others they are two people. In the UK, the king is head of state and the prime minister is head of government.

Monarchies

In a monarchy the head of state is usually a hereditary ruler who holds the position for life, normally passing it to a family member under rules of succession.

There are two broad kinds, introduced in types of political systems.

  • Absolute monarchies: the monarch holds the main political power. Saudi Arabia, Brunei, Oman and Eswatini are often cited.
  • Constitutional monarchies: the monarch's powers are limited by a constitution or by custom. Elected politicians govern, and the monarch performs ceremonial and symbolic duties. Examples include the UK, Japan, Sweden, Norway, Spain, Belgium and the Netherlands.

Japan's postwar constitution (1947) describes the emperor as the symbol of the state and the unity of the people, with no governing powers. Besides the UK, a number of other countries, including Canada, Australia and New Zealand, have the same monarch as their head of state; together these are called Commonwealth realms. A governor-general represents the monarch in each of them.

Why do democracies keep monarchs? Supporters say a monarch gives continuity, stands above party politics and acts as a unifying symbol. Critics say that a hereditary position is unfair and out of step with equality. In practice, the arguments are weighed differently in each country, and some have held votes or discussions on becoming republics.

Republics

In a republic the head of state is not a hereditary monarch. The word comes from Latin res publica, "the public thing" or public affair. Heads of state are chosen by election or appointment, usually for a fixed term.

Republics also divide into two types:

  • Ceremonial presidents, mainly in parliamentary systems. Germany, India, Italy and Ireland are examples: the president is a symbol and referee, while the prime minister or chancellor governs.
  • Executive presidents, who hold real power, as in the United States, Brazil, Mexico and (shared with a prime minister) France. See presidential and parliamentary systems.

Switzerland shows another variation: its government is a seven-member Federal Council, and the presidency rotates among the members each year.

"Republic" does not mean "democracy"

Names can be misleading. A country can be a republic and still be authoritarian, with an unelected or unchallenged president. Many states with "Republic" or "Democratic Republic" in their official name are not free democracies. Equally, a monarchy can be very democratic: Norway and the Netherlands have strong democratic records.

To judge a country, look past the label and ask the questions from the previous lessons: how are leaders chosen, can they be removed peacefully, and do courts and media act independently?

flowchart TD
  A["Head of state"] --> B{"Hereditary?"}
  B -- Yes --> C["Monarchy"]
  B -- No --> D["Republic"]
  C --> C1["Absolute: monarch rules"]
  C --> C2["Constitutional: monarch is symbolic"]
  D --> D1["Ceremonial president"]
  D --> D2["Executive president"]

Two independent questions: is the head of state inherited, and does that person hold real power?

Try it: head of state or head of government?

This program is a simple lookup built from the examples in this lesson. Add more countries to practice.

JS Who holds which role?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The second example counts the examples above by type, which is a small way to practice sorting information.

JS Count by type

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which describes a head of state in a constitutional monarchy?

    In a constitutional monarchy the monarch is a symbol and elected politicians govern.
  2. 2. What does the Latin phrase res publica roughly mean?

    The word republic comes from res publica, a matter that belongs to the public.
  3. 3. Which statement is true?

    The label tells you how the head of state is chosen, not how free the country is.
  4. 4. In which country is the president both head of state and head of government?

    The US president holds both roles. In Germany and India the president is mostly ceremonial.

Summary

  • A head of state symbolizes the nation; a head of government runs the daily business of government. They may be the same person or two.
  • Monarchies have hereditary rulers, absolute or constitutional; republics have non-hereditary heads of state.
  • Republics may have ceremonial or executive presidents.
  • "Republic" and "monarchy" describe how the top job is filled, not whether a country is free.

Next: The United Nations