Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 8 of 37 ยท Government and Power

The Judiciary

Learn how courts work, the difference between criminal and civil cases, how appeals and judicial review function, and why judges must be independent.

The judiciary is the branch of government made up of courts and judges. Its job is to apply the law to specific cases, settle disputes fairly and, in many countries, decide whether laws and government actions respect the constitution. When two neighbors disagree about a fence, or a prosecutor accuses someone of theft, the judiciary decides.

Two main kinds of cases

Type Who is involved Question asked Possible outcome
Criminal The state (prosecution) against a defendant Did the defendant commit a crime? Acquittal, or conviction with a punishment such as a fine or prison
Civil One person or organization against another Who is in the right in this private dispute? Compensation, an order to act or stop acting

In a criminal case the prosecution usually has the burden of proof and must prove guilt to a high standard, often described as "beyond reasonable doubt". In civil cases the usual standard is lower, often "on the balance of probabilities", meaning more likely than not. The exact wording differs between countries.

Other branches of law you may meet are administrative law (disputes between citizens and public bodies), family law and constitutional law.

A court system in layers

Most countries arrange courts in a hierarchy.

  1. Courts of first instance hear a case first, decide facts and apply the law. Trials usually take place here.
  2. Appeal courts review whether the lower court applied the law correctly. They normally do not hear all the evidence again.
  3. A supreme or constitutional court sits at the top, deals with the most important legal questions and its decisions guide all lower courts.
flowchart TD
    A["Court of first instance<br/>hears the case"] --> B["Appeal court<br/>reviews legal errors"]
    B --> C["Supreme court<br/>final decision on the law"]

A typical three-level structure. Real systems add specialist courts for family, labor or administrative matters.

A party who loses may have a right to appeal, but usually only on grounds such as a mistake in law or procedure. This allows errors to be corrected and encourages consistency.

Judges, juries and precedent

In some systems a jury of ordinary citizens decides guilt in serious criminal trials, while in many others professional judges decide alone or with lay assistants. In some courts several judges sit together as a panel.

Legal traditions differ in how much earlier decisions bind later ones.

  • Common law systems (for example England and Wales, the United States, India) give strong weight to precedent: courts follow earlier decisions in similar cases (a principle often called stare decisis).
  • Civil law systems (for example France, Germany, Japan) rely mainly on detailed written codes, and earlier cases guide but bind less formally.

Many countries blend elements of both.

Judicial review

Judicial review is the power of courts to examine laws and government actions and set them aside if they conflict with the constitution or exceed legal authority. In some countries any court can do this. In others a special constitutional court handles it. The United States Supreme Court asserted the power in the 1803 case Marbury v. Madison. Some countries, such as the United Kingdom, traditionally treat Parliament as supreme, so courts interpret laws but cannot strike down Acts of Parliament in the same way, though they can issue declarations about human rights compatibility.

Judicial review does not mean judges "make up the law". Judges are meant to apply the constitution and statutes, and their decisions must be explained in public reasoning that can be criticised and appealed.

Why independence matters

A court that fears the government cannot protect individuals from it. Independence is protected by:

  • security of tenure, so judges cannot be removed for unpopular decisions,
  • protection of salaries,
  • fair and transparent appointment methods,
  • rules against outside pressure on individual cases,
  • open courts and reasoned judgments, so the public can see how decisions are made.

Judges are also expected to be impartial: they must step aside if they have a personal interest in a case.

JS Classify cases: criminal or civil?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

JS Standards of proof as a rough scale

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Courts and ordinary life

Most people meet the judiciary through small matters: a traffic fine, a contract dispute, a family decision. Cases are usually public, and decisions can be reported. Access to justice, meaning the ability to use courts at reasonable cost and speed, is a goal that many countries pursue through legal aid, small-claims courts and mediation.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. In a criminal case, who usually brings the case against the defendant?

    Criminal cases are brought by the state. Civil cases are disputes between private parties.
  2. 2. What does judicial review allow courts to do?

    Judicial review checks the other branches. Its scope differs by country.
  3. 3. What is precedent?

    Precedent is central in common law systems and guides courts to decide similar cases alike.
  4. 4. Which helps protect judicial independence?

    Secure tenure lets judges decide without fear of losing their jobs.

Summary

  • The judiciary applies law to cases, settles disputes and often reviews government action.
  • Criminal cases are state versus defendant; civil cases are disputes between private parties.
  • Courts form a hierarchy with appeals; common law uses precedent strongly, civil law relies on codes.
  • Judicial review lets courts set aside unconstitutional or unlawful acts, in varying forms.
  • Independence, impartiality and open reasoning protect fairness.

Next: Federal and Unitary Governments