Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 25 of 39 · Identical Particles and Atoms

Slater Determinants and the Pauli Principle

Build antisymmetric many-electron wave functions with Slater determinants, see the exchange hole, and compute the Fermi energy of a metal.

With two electrons the antisymmetrized product [ψ_a(1)ψ_b(2) - ψ_a(2)ψ_b(1)]/√2 is easy to write. With 10 electrons there are 10! = 3,628,800 permutations, and writing them by hand is hopeless. The compact solution has been known for a century: a Slater determinant. A determinant automatically has the properties we need, and its algebra encodes the Pauli exclusion principle.

The determinant

Take N single-particle spin-orbitals χ₁, χ₂, …, χ_N. Each spin-orbital is a spatial orbital times a spin function (↑ or ↓). Collect the coordinates of electron i (position and spin) in a single label i. The Slater determinant is

Text
Ψ(1, 2, …, N) = (1/√N!) | χ₁(1)  χ₂(1)  …  χ_N(1) |
                         | χ₁(2)  χ₂(2)  …  χ_N(2) |
                         |  ⋮      ⋮          ⋮    |
                         | χ₁(N)  χ₂(N)  …  χ_N(N) |

Row i holds electron i; column k holds orbital k. Three properties of determinants give everything:

  1. Swapping two rows changes the sign. Swapping two electrons is swapping two rows, so Ψ is antisymmetric.
  2. A determinant with two equal columns is zero. If two spin-orbitals are the same, Ψ = 0. No two electrons may occupy the same spin-orbital: this is the Pauli exclusion principle.
  3. A determinant with two equal rows is zero. If two electrons have the same coordinates (including spin), Ψ = 0. Two electrons of the same spin cannot be at the same point.

The normalization factor 1/√N! assumes the orbitals are orthonormal.

The exclusion principle is not a separate law added to quantum mechanics. It is the consequence of antisymmetry of the many-electron wave function, which is itself the spin-statistics rule for electrons.

Seeing the zeros

The next program builds a determinant of three spin-orbitals in one dimension (the lowest harmonic-oscillator states, all with the same spin) and checks the properties numerically.

Python Slater determinant: antisymmetry and zeros

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The second table shows the Fermi hole (or exchange hole): given an electron at x = 0.3, the density of a second same-spin electron vanishes at x₁ = 0.3 and is reduced nearby. Electrons of the same spin avoid each other, even though the model contains no electron repulsion. Electrons of opposite spin have no such exclusion, so they can be close; this is one reason (together with Coulomb repulsion) that exchange favors parallel spins in atoms, leading to Hund's rules (see Atoms, Shells and Term Symbols).

Pauli pressure and degenerate matter

Fermions have to stack up in energy levels. Consider N free electrons in a box of volume V (a crude model of the conduction electrons in a metal). Each wave vector k holds two electrons (spin up and down). At absolute zero all states up to the Fermi wave vector k_F are filled, with

Text
k_F = (3π² n)^{1/3},      n = N/V

and the Fermi energy

Text
E_F = ħ² k_F² / (2m_e) = (ħ²/2m_e) (3π² n)^{2/3}

This energy, of the order of electron-volts, is vastly larger than the thermal energy k_B T ≈ 0.025 eV at room temperature. Most conduction electrons are frozen in place by the Pauli principle; only those within about k_B T of the Fermi level can be excited. This explains why metals' electronic heat capacity is far below the classical prediction. The same principle, applied to much denser matter, supplies the pressure that supports white dwarf stars against gravity, and with relativistic electrons it leads to the Chandrasekhar limit (about 1.4 solar masses).

Python Fermi energy and temperature of a metal

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The free-electron model is crude (real metals have band structure), but the Fermi energies come out in the right range; for copper, about 7.0 eV and a Fermi temperature near 8 × 10⁴ K.

The permanent for bosons

For bosons the symmetric analog of the determinant is the permanent, which is the same sum with all plus signs. Permanents have no zeros when columns coincide: all N bosons may occupy one orbital, giving a macroscopic ground state, as in Bose-Einstein condensation. Permanents are far harder to compute than determinants (the problem is #P-hard), which is one reason that boson-sampling experiments are interesting for quantum computing.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. Why does a Slater determinant with two identical spin-orbitals vanish?

    Each column is an orbital. Equal orbitals mean equal columns, and a determinant with two equal columns is zero. That is the Pauli exclusion principle.
  2. 2. Two same-spin electrons in a Slater determinant are described without any Coulomb repulsion. Why do they still avoid each other?

    Two equal rows give a zero determinant. The vanishing of Ψ at coinciding coordinates is the Fermi (exchange) hole and has nothing to do with the Coulomb force.
  3. 3. The Fermi energy of a free-electron metal depends on the electron density n as:

    E_F = (ħ²/2m)(3π²n)^(2/3). A denser electron gas must fill higher momentum states.
  4. 4. Why does a metal's electronic heat capacity fall far below the classical value?

    Because E_F is much larger than k_B T, only a small fraction of the electrons has empty states within reach.

Summary

  • A Slater determinant is the antisymmetrized product of N spin-orbitals; it is antisymmetric under row swaps and vanishes for equal columns (Pauli principle) or equal rows (exchange hole).
  • Same-spin electrons avoid each other because of exchange alone, with no force needed.
  • Stacking fermions in energy levels gives the Fermi energy E_F = (ħ²/2m)(3π²n)^{2/3}, typically a few eV in metals.
  • The Pauli principle explains metallic heat capacity and, at high density, supports white dwarfs.
  • Bosons use permanents instead; they have no exclusion.

Next: Helium: Singlet and Triplet States