Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 26 of 39 · Identical Particles and Atoms

Helium: Singlet and Triplet States

See how antisymmetry links spin to energy in helium: build singlet and triplet spin states, then compute the Coulomb and exchange integrals for 1s2s.

The Hamiltonian of helium contains no spin at all: kinetic energy, attraction to the nucleus and electron repulsion. Yet the spectrum of helium splits into two families that were once thought to belong to two different elements, "parahelium" and "orthohelium", with no transitions between them. The splitting is caused by the symmetry rules of the previous lessons. Spin decides whether the spatial wave function is symmetric or antisymmetric, and the spatial symmetry decides how close the two electrons come, hence how much they repel.

Two electron spins

Each electron has spin 1/2. For two electrons, the combined spin states are four in number:

Text
Triplet (S = 1, symmetric):     |↑↑⟩
                                (|↑↓⟩ + |↓↑⟩)/√2
                                |↓↓⟩
Singlet (S = 0, antisymmetric): (|↑↓⟩ - |↓↑⟩)/√2

The three triplet states are symmetric under swapping the two spins, and the singlet is antisymmetric. The total wave function (space times spin) must be antisymmetric, so:

Spin state Spin symmetry Spatial symmetry required
Singlet S = 0 antisymmetric symmetric
Triplet S = 1 symmetric antisymmetric

The spin exchange operator can be written P_spin = (1 + σ₁·σ₂)/2, where σ are the Pauli matrices. Its eigenvalue is +1 on triplet states and -1 on the singlet. The total spin operator is S² = (ħ²/4)(σ₁ + σ₂)², with eigenvalue ħ² S(S+1): 0 for the singlet and 2ħ² for the triplet.

Python Two-spin states, S² and exchange

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The energy splitting

Now add space. Put one electron in an orbital a and the other in b (say 1s and 2s, the lowest excited configuration of helium, 1s2s). The spatial wave functions are

Text
ψ_±(r₁, r₂) = [ a(r₁)b(r₂) ± b(r₁)a(r₂)] / √2

with + for the singlet and - for the triplet. To first order, the repulsion energy ⟨1/r₁₂⟩ in these states splits into

Text
E_± = E_a + E_b + J ± K

J = ∫∫ |a(r₁)|² (1/r₁₂) |b(r₂)|² d³r₁ d³r₂              (direct, or Coulomb, integral)
K = ∫∫ a*(r₁) b*(r₂) (1/r₁₂) b(r₁) a(r₂) d³r₁ d³r₂     (exchange integral)

Both J and K are positive in atoms, so the triplet (-) lies lower than the singlet (+) by 2K.

The physical reason: in the triplet the spatial wave function is antisymmetric and vanishes at r₁ = r₂, so the electrons stay farther apart and repel less. In the singlet they can come close. This is the origin of Hund's first rule: for a given configuration, the state with the highest total spin has the lowest energy.

J is the classical repulsion of two charge clouds. K has no classical analog; it is a purely quantum effect of indistinguishability. It is a spin-independent Coulomb energy: the Hamiltonian has no explicit spin term, but the symmetry requirement makes the energy depend on spin.

Computing J and K for helium 1s2s

For two s orbitals the angular integrals are trivial, and the integrals reduce to the radial one,

Text
∫∫ f(r₁) g(r₂) / max(r₁, r₂) dr₁ dr₂

with f = P_a² and g = P_b² for J, and f = g = P_a P_b for K (P = rR(r), the radial function times r). We use hydrogenic orbitals with Z = 2 (crude, because they ignore screening):

Text
P_1s = 2 Z^{3/2} r e^{-Zr}
P_2s = Z^{3/2} r (1 - Zr/2) e^{-Zr/2} / √2
Python Direct and exchange integrals for He 1s2s

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Look at the output: K is about 1.2 eV, so the predicted gap 2K is about 2.4 eV. Spectroscopy gives roughly 0.8 eV between the 2¹S and 2³S levels, so the hydrogenic estimate is too large by about a factor of three. The reason is that the Z = 2 orbitals ignore screening: the real 2s electron sees a charge close to 1, so it is much more spread out and overlaps the 1s electron far less. The sign and the ordering (triplet lowest) are right; the size needs better orbitals, for example from Hartree-Fock.

Consequences

  • Parahelium and orthohelium. Electric-dipole radiation does not act on spin, so it cannot change S. Transitions between singlet and triplet are therefore strongly suppressed, which is why the two families appear as separate spectra. (Spin-orbit coupling in light atoms is weak, so the selection rule ΔS = 0 holds well in helium.)
  • Metastable 2³S. The lowest triplet state cannot decay to the singlet ground state by an electric-dipole transition, and has a lifetime of about 8000 seconds in the isolated atom. That is a very long life for an excited atomic state.
  • Magnetism. In ferromagnets the same exchange integral aligns neighboring electron spins. The magnetic interaction between spins is tiny; what lines them up is the exchange energy, which is electrostatic in origin.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. For two electrons in different orbitals with a triplet spin state, the spatial wave function is:

    The spin triplet is symmetric, so the spatial part must be antisymmetric to give an antisymmetric total wave function.
  2. 2. In the 1s2s configuration, the triplet lies below the singlet by:

    E_singlet = E_a + E_b + J + K and E_triplet = E_a + E_b + J - K, so the difference is 2K.
  3. 3. Why is the exchange integral K positive for atoms?

    K is the Coulomb self-repulsion of the overlap density a*(r)b(r), which can be shown to be non-negative for the 1/r interaction.
  4. 4. Why is the helium 2³S level metastable?

    The decay to the ground state would require changing S from 1 to 0, which the dipole interaction cannot do; only much weaker processes allow it.

Summary

  • Two spin-1/2 particles form a singlet (S = 0, antisymmetric) and a triplet (S = 1, symmetric).
  • Antisymmetry links the spin state to the spatial symmetry: singlet is spatially symmetric, triplet spatially antisymmetric.
  • The energies are E_a + E_b + J ± K; the triplet lies lower by 2K, giving Hund's first rule.
  • J is the classical direct repulsion; K is a quantum exchange effect.
  • Singlet-triplet transitions are suppressed, producing parahelium and orthohelium and a long-lived metastable state.

Next: The Hartree-Fock Method for Atoms