Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 12 of 39 · Time-Independent Perturbation Theory

Degenerate Perturbation Theory

Learn why nondegenerate formulas fail for degenerate levels, how to diagonalize the perturbation inside the degenerate subspace, and check it in code.

The formulas of the previous lessons contain denominators E⁰ₙ − E⁰ₘ. If two different states have the same unperturbed energy, the denominator vanishes and the formula blows up. Degenerate levels are common in physics: they are the rule, not the exception, whenever there is a symmetry. The remedy is simple in principle: inside a degenerate subspace, you must first find the right states, and the perturbation tells you which they are.

The problem

Suppose level E⁰ is g-fold degenerate, with orthonormal states |1⟩, ..., |g⟩, all satisfying H₀|α⟩ = E⁰|α⟩. Any combination of them is also an eigenstate of H₀. When you switch on λV, the perturbation generally picks out particular combinations and splits the level.

The key observation: as λ → 0, the exact eigenstates of H tend to some combinations of |α⟩, which we do not know in advance. The correct zeroth-order states are those that make the perturbation diagonal within the subspace. Any other choice makes the second-order sum divergent because ⟨β|V|α⟩ ≠ 0 for β ≠ α within the subspace and the denominator is zero.

The procedure

  1. Pick any orthonormal basis {|α⟩} for the degenerate subspace.
  2. Build the g × g matrix Wαβ = ⟨α|V|β⟩, using only states in that subspace.
  3. Diagonalize W. Its eigenvalues are the first-order energy shifts E¹, and its eigenvectors are the correct zeroth-order states.
  4. If the eigenvalues are all distinct, the degeneracy is lifted at first order. Second-order corrections now follow from the usual formulas, summing over states outside the subspace (and over other states in the subspace only if the perturbation does not fully diagonalize).
  5. If some eigenvalues are still equal, the degeneracy persists at first order; look to second order or to symmetry.

Before you diagonalize, look for a symmetry. If an operator S commutes with both H₀ and V and has distinct eigenvalues on the degenerate states, those eigenstates are already the right ones and W is automatically diagonal. This is why angular momentum quantum numbers are so useful in atomic perturbation theory.

Example: coupled oscillator directions

Take the two-dimensional isotropic oscillator H₀ = (p²ₓ + p²ᵧ)/2 + (x² + y²)/2 (units ħ = m = ω = 1). Its energy levels are N + 1 with N = nₓ + nᵧ. The first excited level, E⁰ = 2, is twofold degenerate: |1,0⟩ and |0,1⟩.

Add V = λxy. Its matrix elements are ⟨1,0|xy|1,0⟩ = 0, ⟨0,1|xy|0,1⟩ = 0 and ⟨1,0|xy|0,1⟩ = (1/√2)(1/√2) = 1/2. So

Text
W = λ [ 0    1/2 ]
      [ 1/2  0   ]

with eigenvalues ±λ/2 and eigenvectors (|1,0⟩ ± |0,1⟩)/√2. The level splits symmetrically. Using the non-degenerate formula with |1,0⟩ would give a first-order shift of zero and an infinite second-order term, which is nonsense.

We can check against the exact solution. Rotating coordinates to u = (x+y)/√2, v = (x−y)/√2 gives xy = (u² − v²)/2. So the Hamiltonian describes two independent oscillators with frequencies √(1+λ) and √(1−λ), and the exact energies are √(1+λ)(n_u + ½) + √(1−λ)(n_v + ½).

Python Degenerate splitting: first order versus exact

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

For small λ the two split levels sit at 2 ∓ λ/2 to first order, and the difference grows as λ² for larger λ. The numerical eigenvalues match the closed-form expressions.

A reusable routine

The code below packages the procedure: given an unperturbed Hamiltonian, a perturbation and a target energy, it finds the degenerate subspace, diagonalizes V inside it and returns the first-order shifts together with the correct zeroth-order states.

Python Degenerate first-order perturbation routine

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The small differences are second order in λ, mostly from the coupling to the state at energy 3.

Why it matters in physics

Degenerate perturbation theory explains many effects you will see later: the splitting of the n = 2 level of hydrogen by an electric field (Stark effect), the fine-structure splitting of hydrogen levels by spin–orbit coupling, and Zeeman splitting in a magnetic field. In each case a symmetry-protected degeneracy of H₀ is lifted (fully or partly) by a perturbation that picks out preferred axes or couplings.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. Why do the nondegenerate formulas fail for degenerate levels?

    Within a degenerate subspace Eₙ = Eₘ, so a non-zero matrix element divided by zero is infinite.
  2. 2. What gives the first-order energy shifts in degenerate perturbation theory?

    Diagonalizing the matrix Wαβ = ⟨α|V|β⟩ within the subspace gives the shifts and the correct zeroth-order states.
  3. 3. For V = λxy acting on the n = 1 level of the 2D oscillator, the first-order shifts are

    W has off-diagonal elements λ/2 and zero diagonal, so its eigenvalues are ±λ/2.
  4. 4. A symmetry operator S commutes with H₀ and V. How does this help?

    States with different S eigenvalues have zero matrix element of V between them, so W is already diagonal.

Summary

  • Degenerate levels make the ordinary formulas divergent; the right zeroth-order states must be found first.
  • Diagonalize V inside the degenerate subspace; eigenvalues are first-order shifts, eigenvectors are the correct states.
  • Symmetries that commute with H₀ and V give the right states directly.
  • If a degeneracy survives first order, look at higher orders or a larger symmetry.

Next: The Stark Effect in Hydrogen