Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 24 of 39 Β· Identical Particles and Atoms

Identical Particles and Exchange Symmetry

Understand why identical quantum particles are either symmetric (bosons) or antisymmetric (fermions) under exchange, and see the effect on probabilities.

Two billiard balls can be told apart even if they look the same: follow one with your eyes and you know which is which. Two electrons cannot be followed that way. Quantum mechanics says that all electrons are exactly alike, and that swapping two of them cannot change any measurable quantity. This sounds like a bookkeeping rule. It turns out to determine the structure of atoms, the periodic table, the stability of matter, the behavior of lasers and the properties of metals.

This lesson builds the rules for describing several identical particles and shows the surprising consequence for probabilities, before the next lessons turn it into the Pauli principle and Slater determinants.

The exchange operator

Let ψ(1, 2) be a two-particle wave function, where 1 stands for all the coordinates (position and spin) of the first particle. Define the exchange operator P₁₂ by

Text
P₁₂ ψ(1, 2) = ψ(2, 1)

Applying it twice returns the original function, so P₁₂² = 1 and its eigenvalues are +1 and -1.

If the particles are identical, the Hamiltonian looks the same after relabeling: H(1, 2) = H(2, 1). Then P₁₂ commutes with H, and P₁₂ is conserved. Energy eigenstates can be chosen with a definite exchange parity:

Text
ψ(2, 1) = +ψ(1, 2)     symmetric
ψ(2, 1) = -ψ(1, 2)     antisymmetric

The symmetrization postulate

Logic alone would allow any mixture. Nature uses only two cases for a given kind of particle. This is a postulate of quantum mechanics (confirmed by an enormous number of experiments), not something derived from the SchrΓΆdinger equation:

  • Bosons have wave functions that are symmetric under the exchange of any two of them. Photons, gluons, the Higgs boson, ⁴He atoms and the deuteron are bosons.
  • Fermions have wave functions that are antisymmetric under the exchange of any two. Electrons, protons, neutrons, quarks and neutrinos are fermions.

The two classes are linked to spin. Particles with integer spin (0, 1, 2, …) are bosons and particles with half-integer spin (1/2, 3/2, …) are fermions. The spin-statistics theorem proves this in relativistic quantum field theory; there is no equally simple derivation in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Composite particles follow the same rule: count the fermions inside. A Β³He atom (two protons, one neutron, two electrons: five fermions) is a fermion; ⁴He (six fermions) is a boson. That is why the two isotopes of helium behave so differently at very low temperatures.

Building symmetric and antisymmetric states

Suppose the two particles occupy single-particle states a and b. A product ψ_a(1)ψ_b(2) is neither symmetric nor antisymmetric. Combine it with its exchange partner:

Text
ψ_S = [ψ_a(1)ψ_b(2) + ψ_a(2)ψ_b(1)] / √2     (bosons)
ψ_A = [ψ_a(1)ψ_b(2) - ψ_a(2)ψ_b(1)] / √2     (fermions)

Two immediate consequences:

  • If a = b then ψ_A = 0: two identical fermions cannot be in the same single-particle state. This is the Pauli exclusion principle (next lesson).
  • Bosons can pile into the same state; ψ_a(1)ψ_a(2) is already symmetric.

The exchange effect on probabilities

Even without any force between the particles, the symmetry changes where they are likely to be found. Take two non-interacting particles in an infinite square well of width L = 1, one in state n = 1 and one in n = 2. Compare three descriptions: distinguishable particles (ψ = φ₁(x₁)Ο†β‚‚(xβ‚‚)), bosons (ψ_S) and fermions (ψ_A).

The mean squared separation works out to

Text
⟨(x₁ - xβ‚‚)²⟩ = ⟨xΒ²βŸ©β‚ + ⟨xΒ²βŸ©β‚‚ - 2⟨xβŸ©β‚βŸ¨xβŸ©β‚‚  βˆ“  2 |⟨1|x|2⟩|Β²

where the upper sign is for bosons and the lower for fermions, and the term with βˆ“ is the exchange term. Fermions are on average farther apart than distinguishable particles, and bosons closer. This is an effective "force" with no interaction at all, usually called an exchange force or Pauli repulsion.

Python Mean separation for distinguishable, boson and fermion pairs

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The fermion probability density vanishes on the line x₁ = xβ‚‚: the particles never meet. The boson density is doubled there (apart from normalization). This is the difference between two electrons in a triplet spin state (symmetric in spin, antisymmetric in space) and in a singlet state (the reverse). We will use this in the helium lesson.

Counting states

Exchange symmetry also changes how many distinct states a system has. Put two particles in three single-particle levels. Distinguishable particles have 3 Γ— 3 = 9 states. Bosons have 6 (symmetric combinations, including both in one level) and fermions have 3 (antisymmetric combinations, never both in one level).

Python Counting states for N particles in M levels

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

What spin has to do with it

For electrons the full wave function includes spin: Ξ¨(1, 2) = ψ(r₁, rβ‚‚) Ο‡(s₁, sβ‚‚). The total must be antisymmetric, so either the spatial part is symmetric and the spin part antisymmetric (a singlet, total spin S = 0), or the spatial part is antisymmetric and the spin part symmetric (a triplet, S = 1). Spin does not appear in the Hamiltonian of helium, yet it determines the energy through exchange symmetry. We follow that thread in Helium: Singlet and Triplet States.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. Which is true for two identical fermions?

    Fermions have antisymmetric total wave functions: swapping all coordinates (space and spin) of two particles multiplies Ξ¨ by -1.
  2. 2. A Β³He atom contains 2 protons, 1 neutron and 2 electrons. Is it a boson or a fermion?

    Count the fermions: 2 + 1 + 2 = 5, an odd number, so the composite is a fermion. ⁴He has 6, so it is a boson.
  3. 3. In the square-well example, the fermion density at x₁ = xβ‚‚ is:

    ψ_A(x, x) = [φ₁(x)Ο†β‚‚(x) - Ο†β‚‚(x)φ₁(x)]/√2 = 0, so the particles never occupy the same point.
  4. 4. How many states can 2 bosons have in 3 single-particle levels?

    C(3 + 2 - 1, 2) = C(4, 2) = 6: three states with both bosons in one level, and three with the bosons in different levels.

Summary

  • Identical particles cannot be tracked, so the Hamiltonian commutes with exchange and states have definite exchange symmetry.
  • Bosons (integer spin) are symmetric; fermions (half-integer spin) are antisymmetric. Composites count their fermions.
  • Antisymmetry forbids two fermions in the same state (Pauli principle); bosons may share a state.
  • Exchange symmetry changes mean separations and probabilities even without any force: fermions stay apart, bosons are closer than distinguishable particles.
  • For electrons the spin and spatial parts must combine to an antisymmetric whole.

Next: Slater Determinants and the Pauli Principle