Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 23 of 39 · The Variational Method

LCAO and the Hydrogen Molecule Ion

Use a linear combination of atomic orbitals to explain why a chemical bond forms in H2+, find the equilibrium bond length, and compare with exact values.

Why do two hydrogen atoms form a molecule? The cleanest case to study is the hydrogen molecule ion H₂⁺: two protons and one electron. It is the simplest molecule, and its Schrödinger equation (with the protons held fixed) can be solved exactly in elliptic coordinates. We will not do that. We will use the variational method with a physically motivated trial function, the linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO), and see how a bond arises from two numbers: an overlap integral and an exchange integral.

All lengths here are in Bohr radii and energies in hartree (1 E_h = 27.2114 eV). The nuclei are fixed at separation R (the Born-Oppenheimer approximation: protons are about 1836 times heavier than the electron).

The model

The electronic Hamiltonian is

Text
H = -½∇² - 1/r_A - 1/r_B        (plus the proton repulsion 1/R, added at the end)

where r_A and r_B are the distances from the electron to each proton. When the protons are far apart the electron is in a 1s orbital on one of them: φ_A = e^{-r_A}/√π or φ_B. The LCAO trial function mixes the two:

Text
ψ = c_A φ_A + c_B φ_B

By symmetry, c_A = ±c_B, so there are two states:

Text
ψ_g = (φ_A + φ_B) / √(2(1 + S))        bonding (gerade)
ψ_u = (φ_A - φ_B) / √(2(1 - S))        antibonding (ungerade)

Here S = ⟨φ_A|φ_B⟩ is the overlap.

The integrals

For 1s orbitals the integrals have closed forms in terms of R:

Text
S = e^{-R} (1 + R + R²/3)            overlap
J = 1/R - e^{-2R}(1 + 1/R)           ⟨φ_A| 1/r_B |φ_A⟩   (Coulomb integral)
K = e^{-R}(1 + R)                    ⟨φ_A| 1/r_A |φ_B⟩   (exchange integral)

The total energy (electronic plus proton-proton repulsion) of the two states is

Text
E_g(R) = -1/2 + 1/R - (J + K)/(1 + S)
E_u(R) = -1/2 + 1/R - (J - K)/(1 - S)

The -1/2 is the hydrogen atom energy: the binding energy is measured from H + H⁺ at infinity.

Reading the formula

  • J is a classical electrostatic quantity: the electron cloud around proton A attracts proton B. It nearly cancels the 1/R repulsion at moderate R.
  • K is the quantum part. It comes from the electron density in the overlap region between the nuclei. In the bonding state it adds; in the antibonding state it subtracts. The bond comes from charge piled up between the protons.
Python Potential-energy curves of H2+ in LCAO

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The LCAO curve has a minimum near R ≈ 2.49 bohr (1.32 Å) with a well depth of about 1.76 eV. The exact values are R = 2.00 bohr (1.06 Å) and 2.79 eV. The qualitative picture is right (a bond forms, the antibonding curve is repulsive everywhere) and the quantitative error comes from the rigid 1s orbitals: in the molecule the orbitals should shrink toward the nuclei. Allowing the orbital exponent to be optimized at each R (Finkelstein and Horowitz, 1928) moves the result to roughly 2.35 eV at R ≈ 2.0; adding p polarization functions improves it further. This is the systematic improvement that Rayleigh-Ritz makes possible.

Where the electron is: bonding versus antibonding

The electron density of each state along the molecular axis shows the difference. With normalized 1s orbitals φ = e^{-r}/√π centered at z = ±R/2:

  • In the bonding state the density is enhanced between the nuclei.
  • In the antibonding state there is a node at the midpoint, where φ_A = φ_B and so φ_A - φ_B = 0.
Python Electron density along the bond axis

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The difference between the bonding density and the non-interfering one is the interference term 2φ_Aφ_B, and it is where chemical bonding comes from in this simplest case. In the Hellmann-Feynman picture, the force on each proton is the classical electrostatic force from the electron cloud; the cloud accumulated between the nuclei pulls both protons toward each other.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. The LCAO bonding combination for H₂⁺ is:

    The plus combination adds the amplitudes where they overlap, concentrating electron density between the protons and lowering the energy.
  2. 2. The LCAO result for the H₂⁺ binding energy (1.76 eV) is lower than the exact value (2.79 eV). The main reason is:

    A trial function can only give a bound that is too high (binding too weak). Letting the exponent vary with R, or adding polarization functions, recovers more of the binding.
  3. 3. What does the exchange integral K = e^{-R}(1 + R) mainly describe?

    K involves the product φ_Aφ_B, which is large only where the two atomic orbitals overlap, between the nuclei.
  4. 4. Why is the antibonding curve repulsive at every R?

    With density removed from the region between the protons, the nuclei repel each other with little electronic glue to counter it.

Summary

  • H₂⁺ is the simplest molecule; with fixed nuclei the LCAO trial function φ_A ± φ_B gives two potential-energy curves.
  • The bonding state E_g(R) has a minimum near R = 2.49 bohr and well depth about 1.76 eV (exact: 2.00 bohr, 2.79 eV).
  • Bonding comes from electron density accumulated between the nuclei (the exchange or interference term).
  • The antibonding state has a node at the midpoint and is repulsive.
  • The same method, with larger bases, underlies molecular orbital theory in chemistry.

Next: Identical Particles and Exchange Symmetry