Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 32 of 39 · Scattering Theory

Resonances and the Optical Theorem

Verify the optical theorem numerically for hard-sphere scattering, and see how a resonance appears as a phase shift crossing pi/2 and a Breit-Wigner peak.

Two ideas finish our tour of scattering theory. The optical theorem ties the total cross section to the forward scattering amplitude and is a consequence of conservation of probability. Resonances are the sharp peaks in cross section that mark short-lived intermediate states, from compound nuclei to the particles of high-energy physics. Both are easiest to see in the partial-wave language of the last lesson.

The optical theorem

From f(θ) = (1/k) Σ (2l + 1) e^{iδ_l} sin δ_l P_l(cosθ) and P_l(1) = 1, the forward amplitude is

Text
f(0) = (1/k) Σ (2l + 1) e^{iδ_l} sin δ_l

so its imaginary part is Im f(0) = (1/k) Σ (2l + 1) sin² δ_l. Compare with σ = (4π/k²) Σ (2l + 1) sin² δ_l:

Text
σ_total = (4π/k) Im f(0)

This is the optical theorem. It holds for elastic plus inelastic scattering too (then σ is the total cross section and the identity is more general). The physical reason is interference: the forward-scattered wave interferes destructively with the incident wave. That removes flux from the forward beam: the "shadow". The amount removed equals everything scattered elsewhere, because probability is conserved. The theorem is used in particle physics to deduce total cross sections from forward measurements.

The test below uses the hard sphere, where the amplitude is easy to compute. We compute f(θ) on a fine angular grid, integrate |f|² over the sphere, and compare with 4π Im f(0)/k and the partial-wave sum.

Python Check the optical theorem for a hard sphere

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The three values agree. Notice that the optical theorem needs only f(0), the amplitude in a single direction, to give an integral over all directions.

Resonances

Suppose a short-range potential has a barrier (for example the centrifugal barrier plus a nuclear force) that can briefly trap a particle with an energy slightly above zero. The particle can leak out only by tunneling, so it spends a relatively long time inside a quasi-bound state at energy E_R before escaping. In the cross section this shows up as a narrow peak at E ≈ E_R.

Near a resonance in partial wave l the phase shift rises rapidly through π/2:

Text
tan δ_l ≈ (Γ/2) / (E_R - E)

giving the Breit-Wigner formula:

Text
sin² δ_l = (Γ/2)² / [ (E - E_R)² + (Γ/2)² ]
σ_l = (4π/k²)(2l + 1) (Γ/2)² / [ (E - E_R)² + (Γ/2)² ]

The peak reaches the unitarity limit 4π(2l + 1)/k² at E = E_R, and Γ is the full width at half maximum. The resonance has a lifetime

Text
τ = ħ / Γ

which is the energy-time uncertainty relation in disguise: a state that lives for τ has an energy spread Γ ≈ ħ/τ. A related quantity, the Wigner time delay 2ħ dδ/dE, measures how long the wave packet stays near the scatterer; at the center of a Breit-Wigner peak it equals 4ħ/Γ, a few lifetimes, and it is positive.

The Argand diagram

The partial-wave amplitude a_l = e^{iδ_l} sin δ_l lies on a circle of radius 1/2 centered at i/2 in the complex plane (since a_l = (e^{2iδ_l} - 1)/2i). As the energy sweeps through a resonance, the point runs counterclockwise around the circle, passing through the top (a = i, δ = π/2) at E = E_R. This signature distinguishes a true resonance from a smooth rise in cross section.

Python Breit-Wigner resonance: phase shift, cross section, width and lifetime

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The Delta (Δ) resonance is the lowest excited state of the nucleon, seen as a peak in pion-nucleon scattering with mass near 1232 MeV/c² and a width of order 117 MeV. The last lines of the program show what that width means as a lifetime: about 6 × 10⁻²⁴ s, far too short to see a track, but readable from the width of the peak. This is how most particle lifetimes in the strong-interaction domain are measured.

Resonances beyond the simple picture

  • Narrow versus overlapping. The Breit-Wigner form assumes an isolated resonance. When resonances overlap, they interfere and the cross section is more complicated.
  • Fano profiles. If a resonance interferes with a smooth background, the peak becomes an asymmetric dip-and-peak pattern.
  • Complex energy. A resonance can be described as a pole of the scattering amplitude at complex energy E_R - iΓ/2. This is the formal definition used in advanced treatments.
  • Ramsauer-Townsend effect. The opposite extreme is a phase shift passing through a multiple of π, so that sin δ₀ = 0. The low-energy cross section of an atom nearly vanishes: electrons of the right energy pass through argon atoms almost unscattered. This was observed in the 1920s and cannot be explained classically.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. The optical theorem relates the total cross section to:

    Because the forward-scattered wave interferes with the incident wave, the flux removed from the forward beam is determined by Im f(0).
  2. 2. At the peak of a Breit-Wigner resonance in partial wave l, the phase shift is:

    tan δ = (Γ/2)/(E_R - E) diverges at E = E_R, so δ = π/2 and sin²δ = 1: the unitarity limit.
  3. 3. A resonance has a width Γ = 117 MeV. Its lifetime is of the order of:

    τ = ħ/Γ = 6.58 × 10⁻²² MeV·s / 117 MeV ≈ 5.6 × 10⁻²⁴ s.
  4. 4. On an Argand diagram of e^{iδ} sin δ, a resonance appears as:

    e^{iδ}sinδ = (e^{2iδ} - 1)/2i lies on that circle; δ increasing through π/2 moves the point around it.

Summary

  • The optical theorem σ = (4π/k) Im f(0) follows from the partial-wave sums and expresses conservation of probability.
  • A resonance is a quasi-bound state: the phase shift rises through π/2 and the cross section follows the Breit-Wigner shape.
  • Γ (full width at half maximum) and lifetime are connected by τ = ħ/Γ.
  • On the Argand diagram e^{iδ} sin δ runs around a circle of radius 1/2.
  • Strong-interaction resonances such as the Δ(1232) live about 10⁻²⁴ s, measurable only through their widths.

Next: Density Matrices and Mixed States