Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 34 of 37 · Coordinate Geometry and Proof

Writing Geometry Proofs

Learn what a proof is, how to write two-column and paragraph proofs, use givens, definitions and theorems, and avoid common logic errors, with examples and code.

A proof is a chain of logical steps showing that a statement must be true. In geometry, you start from facts you are given, use definitions and already-proved theorems, and arrive at the claim. Proofs are not about being clever; they are about being clear. Every step needs a reason, and every reason must be something that you are allowed to use.

The ingredients

  • Given: the facts the problem tells you.
  • Prove: the statement you must show.
  • Definitions: precise meanings, for example "a midpoint divides a segment into two equal parts".
  • Postulates (axioms): basic facts accepted without proof, such as "two points determine exactly one line".
  • Theorems: statements already proved, such as "the base angles of an isosceles triangle are equal".
  • Diagram: always draw and label it, but never rely on the picture alone. A diagram can mislead you about equal lengths or right angles.

Two-column proofs

A two-column proof lists statements on the left and the reason for each on the right. Each statement must follow from earlier lines.

Problem. Segments AB and CD cross at M. Given: M is the midpoint of AB and also the midpoint of CD. Prove: △AMC ≅ △BMD.

Statement Reason
1. AM = MB Given
2. CM = MD Given
3. ∠AMC = ∠BMD Vertical angles are equal
4. △AMC ≅ △BMD SAS (two sides and the included angle)

Notice how each reason is a named rule, not "it looks like it". The angles in line 3 sit between the equal sides, so SAS applies.

Paragraph proofs

A paragraph proof says the same thing in sentences. It reads like a short explanation, but every claim still carries a reason.

Proof. Because M is the midpoint of both AB and CD, AM = MB and CM = MD. The angles ∠AMC and ∠BMD are vertical angles, so they are equal. Therefore the triangles AMC and BMD have two pairs of equal sides with equal angles between them, and by SAS they are congruent. ∎

The symbol ∎ marks the end of a proof, like Q.E.D.

A second example: base angles of an isosceles triangle

Given: △ABC with AB = AC. Prove: ∠B = ∠C.

  1. Draw the bisector of ∠A meeting BC at D. (A construction. You are allowed to add lines, and you should say so.)
  2. AB = AC (given).
  3. ∠BAD = ∠CAD (by the way AD was drawn).
  4. AD = AD (common side).
  5. So △ABD ≅ △ACD by SAS.
  6. Therefore ∠B = ∠C because corresponding parts of congruent triangles are equal (CPCTC).

Step 6 is the point of the whole argument: prove the triangles congruent first, then conclude about their parts.

flowchart LR
    A["Given facts"] --> B["Definitions and theorems"]
    B --> C["Intermediate steps"]
    C --> D["Statement to prove"]

Each arrow is a logical step that needs a reason.

How to find a proof

  1. Mark the givens on your diagram.
  2. Write down what you must prove and what would let you prove it ("to show two segments equal, it is enough to show that they are corresponding sides of congruent triangles").
  3. Work backward from the goal and forward from the givens until they meet.
  4. Write the clean proof in order.

If you are stuck, ask: what is each given fact good for? A midpoint gives equal segments. A bisector gives equal angles. Parallel lines give equal alternate angles. A right angle lets you use Pythagoras.

Common logic errors

  • Assuming what you want to prove (circular reasoning). Do not use the conclusion as a reason.
  • Relying on the picture. "It looks like a right angle" is not a reason. Use only what is given or already proved.
  • Using a converse without proof. "If p then q" does not mean "if q then p". A rectangle has equal diagonals, but equal diagonals alone do not make a quadrilateral a rectangle (an isosceles trapezoid also has them).
  • Proving only one example. Specific numbers or one diagram do not prove a general statement.

Counterexamples

To show a statement is false you need only one counterexample: a case where the conditions hold but the conclusion fails. The claim "if a quadrilateral has equal diagonals, it is a rectangle" is false, and an isosceles trapezoid is the counterexample. A program can search for counterexamples too. In this runner, we test the claim with coordinates.

Python Search for a counterexample

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

A proof outline keeper

Here is a small helper that stores a proof as numbered statements and reasons, and checks that each line only cites earlier lines. It does not judge whether the geometry is true; it only checks structure, like a proofreader. It is a demonstration of how rigorous proofs are built, not a theorem prover.

Python A two-column proof with a structure check

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. In a two-column proof, what goes in the right-hand column?

    Each statement on the left needs a justification on the right, such as Given, a definition, a postulate or a theorem.
  2. 2. Which is a valid reason in a proof?

    A theorem that has already been proved is a valid reason. Appearance and obviousness are not.
  3. 3. To show that a statement is false you need:

    One case where the conditions hold but the conclusion fails is enough to disprove a general claim.
  4. 4. What does CPCTC stand for?

    Once triangles are shown congruent, all their corresponding sides and angles are equal.

Summary

  • A proof is a chain of statements, each justified by a given, a definition, a postulate or a proved theorem.
  • Two-column proofs list statement and reason; paragraph proofs say the same in sentences.
  • Prove triangles congruent first, then use CPCTC.
  • Avoid circular reasoning and conclusions drawn from a picture.
  • One counterexample disproves a general claim.

Next: Practice Set: Circles and Area