Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 22 of 38 · Trigonometric Identities

Proving Trigonometric Identities

Learn practical strategies for proving trig identities, work through four examples, and use a numeric tester to catch false identities before you start.

To prove an identity means to show, using algebra and known identities, that two expressions are equal wherever they are defined. There is no single recipe, but a handful of habits solve most problems. This lesson gives you those habits, four fully worked proofs, and a small program that helps you decide whether a claimed identity is even worth trying to prove.

The rules of the game

  1. Work on one side at a time, usually the more complicated one, and transform it until it matches the other side.
  2. Do not move terms across the equals sign or multiply both sides by something. That assumes what you want to prove. (Cross-multiplying is fine if you do it as a separate, clearly justified step, as in Example 2.)
  3. Write each step so that a reader could see which identity you used.

Strategies that work

  • Convert to sine and cosine. Replace tan, cot, sec, csc with sin and cos, then simplify.
  • Use a Pythagorean identity to swap sin² for 1 − cos² (or the reverse), or 1 + tan² for sec².
  • Combine fractions over a common denominator, or split one fraction into two.
  • Multiply by a conjugate, such as (1 − sin x)/(1 − sin x), to create a difference of squares.
  • Factor expressions such as sin²x − cos²x or 1 − sin²x.
  • Look at the target side for hints about which form to aim for.

Example 1: sec x − cos x = sin x tan x

Start with the left side and convert to sine and cosine.

Text
sec x − cos x = 1/cos x − cos x
              = (1 − cos²x) / cos x      (common denominator)
              = sin²x / cos x            (Pythagorean identity)
              = sin x · (sin x / cos x)
              = sin x tan x

The left side now equals the right side.

Example 2: (1 + sin x) / cos x = cos x / (1 − sin x)

Here the conjugate idea is useful. Multiply the left side's numerator and denominator by 1 − sin x (this equals multiplying by 1, so it is allowed):

Text
(1 + sin x) / cos x = (1 + sin x)(1 − sin x) / [cos x (1 − sin x)]
                    = (1 − sin²x) / [cos x (1 − sin x)]
                    = cos²x / [cos x (1 − sin x)]
                    = cos x / (1 − sin x)

This holds where cos x ≠ 0 and sin x ≠ 1 (both sides are undefined where cos x = 0).

Example 3: (sin x + cos x)² = 1 + sin 2x

Expand the left side:

Text
(sin x + cos x)² = sin²x + 2 sin x cos x + cos²x
                 = (sin²x + cos²x) + 2 sin x cos x
                 = 1 + sin 2x

Recognizing 2 sin x cos x as the double-angle formula finishes the proof.

Example 4: tan x + cot x = sec x csc x

Text
tan x + cot x = sin x/cos x + cos x/sin x
              = (sin²x + cos²x) / (sin x cos x)
              = 1 / (sin x cos x)
              = (1/cos x)(1/sin x)
              = sec x csc x
Python Numeric identity tester

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

A passing test is only evidence. A failing test is a genuine counterexample and saves you from trying to prove something false.

Checking with a computer algebra system

SymPy can reduce an expression to simplest form. If lhs − rhs simplifies to 0, that is a strong check (still not a classroom proof, because it does not show your steps).

Python Let SymPy check the difference

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

For the identities the difference is 0; for the false one, sin 2x − 2 sin x, SymPy cannot reduce it to zero.

Common pitfalls

  • Dividing by an expression that might be zero without noting it.
  • Squaring both sides of a proof (this can create false "identities").
  • Forgetting that sin²x means (sin x)².
  • Stopping when both sides are "close" instead of identical.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 3 questions

of 3 answered You scored / 3 · perfect!

  1. 1. Which approach is NOT allowed when proving an identity?

    Adding to both sides assumes the identity is true, which is what you are trying to prove. Work on one side only.
  2. 2. In the proof of sec x − cos x = sin x tan x, which identity turns 1 − cos²x into sin²x?

    sin²x + cos²x = 1 rearranges to 1 − cos²x = sin²x.
  3. 3. A numeric test finds that two expressions agree at 2000 random angles. What does that show?

    Agreement at sample points suggests an identity but does not prove it. Only a counterexample is conclusive.

Summary

  • Work on one side, usually the more complicated one.
  • Convert to sine and cosine, use Pythagorean identities, combine or split fractions, multiply by conjugates, factor.
  • Never assume the result by operating on both sides.
  • A numeric test can quickly find false claims; it cannot prove true ones.
  • Note where an identity is undefined (zero denominators).

Next: Inverse Trigonometric Functions