Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 22 of 38 · Particle in a Box and Barriers

Quantum Tunneling Through a Barrier

Derive the tunneling probability through a rectangular barrier, compare exact and thick-barrier formulas, and see why a scanning tunneling microscope works.

A ball rolling toward a hill that is higher than its energy always turns back. A quantum particle can appear on the far side. This is quantum tunneling, and it is not a rare curiosity: it powers the scanning tunneling microscope, flash memory, tunnel diodes and the radioactive decay of many nuclei. It also helps stars fuse hydrogen at temperatures lower than a purely classical calculation would need.

Tunneling follows directly from what you saw in the last two lessons: a wave decays inside a forbidden region instead of stopping dead. If the region is thin enough, some wave is still left when it reaches the other side.

The rectangular barrier

Take a barrier of height V₀ and width a:

Text
V(x) = 0     for x < 0
V(x) = V₀    for 0 < x < a
V(x) = 0     for x > a

A particle with energy E < V₀ comes from the left. In the three regions the solutions are

Text
x < 0:       ψ = e^{ikx} + r e^{-ikx}              k = √(2mE)/ħ
0 < x < a:   ψ = B e^{κx} + C e^{-κx}              κ = √(2m(V₀ - E))/ħ
x > a:       ψ = t e^{ikx}

Inside the barrier both exponentials are kept: the growing one is needed because the wave must be able to "reach" the second boundary and match the outgoing wave. Matching ψ and ψ' at x = 0 and x = a gives four equations for r, B, C, t. Solving them (a standard but tedious exercise) gives the transmission probability

Text
T = 1 / ( 1 + V₀² sinh²(κa) / (4 E (V₀ - E)) )

The function sinh is the hyperbolic sine, sinh(y) = (e^y - e^{-y}) / 2. The reflection coefficient is R = 1 - T.

The thick-barrier approximation

When κa ≫ 1, sinh(κa) ≈ e^{κa} / 2 and the formula simplifies to

Text
T ≈ 16 (E / V₀) (1 - E / V₀) e^{-2κa}

The factor in front is of order 1 (it is largest, equal to 4, at E = V₀/2). The approximation is only valid for κa ≫ 1: for a thin barrier it can give a value above 1, which is impossible for a probability (the first row of the table below shows this). The important part is the exponential:

Text
T ∝ e^{-2κa},    κ = √(2m(V₀ - E)) / ħ

Tunneling probability falls exponentially with barrier width and with the square root of the "missing" energy times mass. Three consequences:

  • Doubling the width squares the (small) probability.
  • Heavy particles tunnel far less than light ones, because κ ∝ √m.
  • A small change in width gives a huge change in current: the basis of the scanning tunneling microscope.

Worked example

An electron with E = 1.0 eV meets a barrier of V₀ = 2.0 eV and width a = 0.5 nm. Then

Text
κ = √(2 m_e (1 eV)) / ħ ≈ 5.12 × 10⁹ m⁻¹
κ a ≈ 2.56

You can compute the exact T with the formula; the editor below does it and compares with the approximation as a grows.

Python Exact vs. thick-barrier tunneling probability

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

You should see the two columns agree better as κa grows, and the proton's probability is tiny: about 10⁻⁹⁵ for this barrier: for practical purposes, zero.

Above the barrier: resonances

If E > V₀ the classical answer is "always transmitted", but the exact formula is

Text
T = 1 / ( 1 + V₀² sin²(k₂ a) / (4 E (E - V₀)) ),    k₂ = √(2m(E - V₀)) / ħ

This equals exactly 1 when k₂ a = nπ, that is, when a whole number of half-wavelengths fits inside the barrier. At these resonances the reflections from the two edges cancel. Between them T < 1. This is the same physics as an anti-reflection coating on a lens, and it is why the plot below shows oscillations above E = V₀.

Python Transmission vs. energy: tunneling and resonances

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Application: the scanning tunneling microscope

In a scanning tunneling microscope (STM), a sharp metal tip is held within about a nanometer of a conducting surface. A small voltage drives electrons across the vacuum gap, which acts as a barrier of height comparable with the metal work function (a few eV; about 4 to 5 eV is typical for many metals). The current is proportional to the tunneling probability, so

Text
I ∝ e^{-2κ d}

with gap d. For a barrier of about 4.5 eV, κ = √(2mφ)/ħ ≈ 1.09 × 10¹⁰ m⁻¹, so a change in d of only 0.1 nm changes the current by a factor of about 9. By scanning and keeping the current constant, the tip height maps out the surface with sub-atomic vertical resolution. (The estimate is an idealized one-dimensional model; real tips and surfaces are more complex, but the exponential sensitivity is real.)

Other examples, stated carefully

  • Alpha decay: an alpha particle inside a nucleus faces a Coulomb barrier. Its tunneling probability, roughly an exponential of a large negative number, explains why half-lives range over an enormous span of timescales. This was one of the first successes of quantum mechanics (Gamow, 1928).
  • Tunnel diodes and flash memory use tunneling of electrons through thin insulating layers.
  • Stars: protons must get very close to fuse, and tunneling through the Coulomb barrier makes fusion happen at the core temperatures of the Sun.

Do not picture the particle "digging through" the barrier at a certain speed. The wavefunction has a nonzero value on the other side, and the tunneling probability is a probability to be found there, not a classical trajectory. Avoid the claim that tunneling lets particles move faster than light: it does not carry signals that way.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. In the thick-barrier limit, the tunneling probability depends mainly on

    The exponential e^(−2κa) dominates. The prefactor 16(E/V₀)(1 − E/V₀) is of order 1.
  2. 2. An electron and a proton (same energy) meet the same barrier. Which statement is correct?

    κ grows with the square root of the mass, and T falls exponentially with κ, so heavier particles tunnel much less.
  3. 3. For E > V₀, the transmission through a rectangular barrier equals 1 when

    When sin(k₂a) = 0, the reflections from the two edges cancel, giving perfect transmission (a resonance).
  4. 4. In an STM, why does a tiny change in tip height change the current so much?

    I ∝ e^(−2κd), so each additional 0.1 nm of gap reduces the current by a large factor.

Summary

  • A particle with E < V₀ has a decaying wave inside the barrier; if the barrier is thin, a transmitted wave emerges.
  • Exact: T = 1 / (1 + V₀² sinh²(κa) / (4E(V₀ − E))). Thick barrier: T ≈ 16(E/V₀)(1 − E/V₀) e^{−2κa}.
  • T falls exponentially with width and with √m, which is why electrons tunnel readily and everyday objects effectively never do.
  • For E > V₀, T oscillates and reaches 1 at resonances k₂a = nπ.
  • Applications include the scanning tunneling microscope, alpha decay, tunnel diodes and stellar fusion.

Next: Solving the Schrödinger Equation Numerically