Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 26 of 37 ยท Fiscal and Monetary Policy

Budget Deficits and Public Debt

Learn the difference between deficit and debt, the primary balance, the debt-to-GDP ratio and the simple rule that decides whether public debt grows or shrinks.

News reports often mix up two ideas: the deficit and the debt. They are different. A deficit is a flow (a yearly amount), while debt is a stock (the total accumulated at one moment). Think of a bathtub: the deficit is the water flowing in this year, and the debt is the water level.

This lesson defines the main terms, shows how the debt ratio evolves, and explains why growth and interest rates matter as much as the budget itself.

Deficit, surplus and debt

Each year, the government's budget balance is revenue minus total spending.

  • If spending exceeds revenue, there is a budget deficit.
  • If revenue exceeds spending, there is a budget surplus.
  • If they are equal, the budget is balanced.

A deficit is financed by borrowing, usually by selling bonds. The public debt (or national debt) is the total of all past borrowing not yet repaid, so

debt at end of year = debt at start of year + deficit

Public debt is not the same as external debt (what the country as a whole owes foreigners). A government may owe mostly its own citizens.

Primary balance and interest

Spending includes interest payments on existing debt. The primary balance is revenue minus spending excluding interest. A primary deficit means that the government is spending more than it collects on everything except interest.

total deficit = primary deficit + interest payments

The primary balance shows what policy choices the government is making today; interest is a cost of past decisions.

Cyclical and structural deficits

Part of a deficit is caused by the business cycle: in a recession, tax revenue falls and benefit payments rise automatically. This is the cyclical deficit. It shrinks when the economy recovers. The structural deficit remains even when the economy is at full employment. Policymakers care mainly about the structural part.

Why the ratio to GDP matters

A debt of 500 billion is huge for a small economy and small for a giant one. So economists compare debt with income: the debt-to-GDP ratio. If the ratio is stable, the debt is manageable even if the amount grows every year, just as a household can carry a larger mortgage as its income grows.

The ratio changes for two reasons: the debt grows (borrowing plus interest) and GDP grows. A useful approximation, with the debt ratio d, the nominal interest rate r on debt, the nominal GDP growth rate g and the primary deficit p (as a share of GDP):

d_next = d ร— (1 + r) / (1 + g) + p

The key term is (r - g). If the interest rate on the debt is higher than the growth rate of GDP, the debt ratio rises on its own, even with a balanced primary budget. If r is below g, the ratio shrinks on its own.

Python Debt-to-GDP simulator

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The scenarios show that the same primary balance can mean a rising or a falling debt ratio, depending on r - g.

The stabilizing primary balance

How large a primary surplus keeps the debt ratio constant? Set d_next = d and solve:

p = -d ร— (r - g) / (1 + g)

(A negative p is a surplus.) With d = 60, r = 3 and g = 2 (percent), the primary surplus needed is 60 ร— 0.01 / 1.02, about 0.59 percent of GDP.

Python Primary surplus needed to hold the ratio constant

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

A negative result in the last line means the country could even run a small primary deficit and keep the ratio stable, because growth beats the interest rate.

Is public debt bad?

The honest answer: it depends. Arguments in favor of borrowing:

  • It lets the government smooth spending over time and respond to recessions or emergencies.
  • It can finance investment, such as roads or schools, that benefits future generations too.

Arguments for caution:

  • Interest costs take money from other uses. Higher debt can mean higher taxes later.
  • Crowding out: heavy government borrowing may raise interest rates and reduce private investment.
  • Risk of crisis: if lenders lose confidence, borrowing costs can jump. This risk is larger when debt is owed in a foreign currency or when the country cannot print its own currency.
  • Less room to respond to the next crisis.

Some economists argue about Ricardian equivalence: if households expect future taxes to repay today's debt, they may save more now, which would cancel part of the stimulus. Evidence suggests this holds only partly.

Debt and deficits are measured differently in different countries (central government, general government, gross or net of assets). When you compare countries, check the definition used by the data source.

Financing a deficit

A government can finance a deficit by:

  1. Borrowing from the public by selling bonds (may raise interest rates).
  2. Borrowing from abroad (raises external debt).
  3. Selling assets, such as state-owned companies.
  4. Borrowing from the central bank, which creates money and can cause inflation. In many countries, laws limit or forbid this directly.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A government has a deficit of 20 this year and had debt of 300 at the start of the year. What is the debt at the end of the year?

    Debt rises by the amount of the deficit: 300 + 20 = 320.
  2. 2. What is the primary balance?

    The primary balance leaves out interest payments, so it shows the current policy stance.
  3. 3. If r is greater than g and the primary balance is zero, the debt-to-GDP ratio will

    Interest accumulates faster than GDP grows, so the ratio rises by itself.
  4. 4. Which is a cyclical deficit?

    A cyclical deficit comes from the business cycle and tends to disappear when the economy recovers.

Summary

  • A deficit is a yearly flow; debt is the accumulated stock.
  • Primary balance excludes interest; total deficit = primary deficit + interest.
  • Cyclical deficits follow the business cycle; structural deficits remain at full employment.
  • The debt ratio evolves as d ร— (1 + r) / (1 + g) + p; whether r exceeds g is crucial.
  • Debt can be useful for smoothing and investment, but high debt carries interest, crowding-out and confidence risks.

Next: Monetary Policy: Interest Rates and Inflation Targets