Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 35 of 36 ยท Projects and Practice

Practice: Products, Quotients and Surfaces

Worked exercises on product and quotient topologies, polygon gluing, Euler characteristic and the fundamental group, with code to check your answers.

This second practice set covers the last three chapters' tools: product topology, quotient topology, surfaces and the fundamental group. Attempt each problem before reading its solution, then run the code to compare. Two short reminders:

  • A set U in X/~ is open iff qโปยน(U) is open in X.
  • A closed connected surface is determined by its orientability and its Euler characteristic.

Problem set A: products

  1. Show that the projection ฯ€โ‚: โ„ยฒ โ†’ โ„ is an open map but not a closed map.
  2. X is compact and Y is compact. Is X ร— Y compact? Why?
  3. Is the product of two disconnected spaces ever connected?
  4. The unit circle Sยน and [0, 1] are given. Describe Sยน ร— [0, 1] and give its Euler characteristic (as a surface with boundary: V โˆ’ E + F of a grid).
  5. Let X have m points with the discrete topology and Y have n points with the discrete topology. How many open sets does X ร— Y have?

Solutions.

  1. A basic open set U ร— V projects to U (open, or empty if V is empty); unions of rectangles project to unions, so ฯ€โ‚ is open. It is not closed: the set {(x, y) : xy = 1} is closed in โ„ยฒ but its projection is โ„ \ {0}, which is not closed.
  2. Yes, this is the finite case of Tychonoff's theorem (via the tube lemma).
  3. No. If X is disconnected with a separation U โˆช V then (U ร— Y) โˆช (V ร— Y) is a separation of X ร— Y.
  4. A cylinder. A grid of m ร— n squares on a cylinder (columns glued) has V = m(n + 1), E = m(n + 1) + mn and F = mn, giving ฯ‡ = 0.
  5. Every subset of X ร— Y is open (single points {(x, y)} = {x} ร— {y} are open), so there are 2^{mn} open sets.

Problem set B: quotients

  1. Describe [0, 1] ร— [0, 1] with (x, 0) ~ (x, 1) only.
  2. The sphere Sยฒ with antipodal points identified, p ~ โˆ’p: what surface is it?
  3. Let X = โ„ and x ~ y iff x โˆ’ y โˆˆ โ„ค. Show the quotient is compact.
  4. Let f: [0, 1] โ†’ X be continuous with f(0) = f(1). Show that f factors through the circle.
  5. Decide whether โ„ with x ~ y iff x โˆ’ y โˆˆ โ„š is Hausdorff.

Solutions.

  1. A cylinder Sยน ร— [0, 1].
  2. The real projective plane, with ฯ‡ = 1: the sphere has ฯ‡ = 2 and the identification is two-to-one on all of it.
  3. It is the image of the compact set [0, 1] under the continuous quotient map, hence compact.
  4. f is constant on the classes of the gluing 0 ~ 1, so by the universal property it descends to a continuous map from the quotient, which is the circle.
  5. No. Every nonempty open saturated set is everything, so the quotient is indiscrete and points cannot be separated.

The program checks the counting claim of problem 5 by brute force on small examples.

Python Counting open sets of a product of discrete spaces

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Problem set C: surfaces

  1. Classify the surfaces given by the words abAB, aabb and abcABC.
  2. A closed surface has ฯ‡ = โˆ’2. List the orientable and the non-orientable possibilities.
  3. A torus is cut along one meridian circle. What do you get? Along two disjoint ones?
  4. Is the surface of a coffee cup with one handle homeomorphic to a doughnut surface? To a sphere?
  5. How many different closed surfaces (up to homeomorphism) have ฯ‡ = 0?

Solutions.

  1. abAB is the torus and aabb is the Klein bottle. The hexagon word abcABC is also a torus (the standard hexagonal picture of the torus with opposite sides glued); the code confirms ฯ‡ = 0 and orientability.
  2. Orientable: genus 2 (double torus). Non-orientable: k = 4 crosscaps. These are the only two.
  3. One cut gives a cylinder. Two disjoint meridian cuts split the torus into two cylinders.
  4. A cup with one handle is homeomorphic to the doughnut surface (genus 1), not to a sphere.
  5. Two: the torus (orientable) and the Klein bottle (non-orientable).

The classifier below handles problem 11 and also counts how many of the labelled words with two letters give each surface.

Python Classify all two-letter polygon words

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

All 96 words land in one of four classes: the sphere, the projective plane, the torus and the Klein bottle (a polygon with four edges, glued in pairs, yields no other closed surface).

Problem set D: the fundamental group

  1. What is ฯ€โ‚ of the closed disk? Of the plane minus two points?
  2. Show that a continuous retraction of the closed disk onto its boundary circle cannot exist.
  3. A loop in the punctured plane winds 3 times counterclockwise, another winds โˆ’1 times. What is the winding number of their concatenation?
  4. Which of the surfaces sphere, torus, projective plane has a nontrivial finite ฯ€โ‚?

Solutions. (16) Trivial for the disk; for the plane minus two points it is the free group on two generators (not abelian). (17) A retraction r: Dยฒ โ†’ Sยน with r|_{Sยน} = id would give ฯ€โ‚(Sยน) โ†’ ฯ€โ‚(Dยฒ) โ†’ ฯ€โ‚(Sยน) equal to the identity, but the middle group is trivial while โ„ค is not. (18) 3 + (โˆ’1) = 2. (19) The projective plane, with ฯ€โ‚ = โ„ค/2.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 3 questions

of 3 answered You scored / 3 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. How many open sets does a product of discrete spaces with m and n points have?

    All singletons are open, so every subset of the mยทn points is open.
  2. 2. Is the projection โ„ยฒ โ†’ โ„ a closed map?

    Projections are open and continuous, but the hyperbola's image misses 0, so the image of a closed set is not closed.
  3. 3. What is the Euler characteristic of the connected sum of two projective planes?

    ฯ‡ = 1 + 1 โˆ’ 2 = 0. The result is the Klein bottle.

Summary

  • Products of discrete spaces are discrete; products of compact (connected) spaces are compact (connected).
  • Projections are open maps but need not be closed.
  • Quotients of compact spaces are compact; their topology is defined through preimages.
  • ฯ‡(Sโ‚ # Sโ‚‚) = ฯ‡(Sโ‚) + ฯ‡(Sโ‚‚) โˆ’ 2; surfaces are fixed by orientability and ฯ‡.
  • ฯ€โ‚ distinguishes spaces that other invariants cannot, for example a retraction of the disk onto its boundary is impossible.

Next: Project: A Small Topology Toolkit