Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 32 of 36 Β· Surfaces and the Fundamental Group

Classification of Closed Surfaces

Every closed surface is a sphere, a sum of tori or a sum of projective planes. Learn the theorem, the normal forms, and classify surfaces by code.

How many different closed surfaces are there? Infinitely many, but they fall into two neat families. The classification theorem of closed surfaces is one of the finest results of 2-dimensional topology: it gives a complete list, so that to decide whether two closed surfaces are homeomorphic you only need to compute two numbers, orientability and Euler characteristic.

Connected sums

To combine two surfaces S₁ and Sβ‚‚, cut a small open disk out of each and glue the two boundary circles together. The result is the connected sum S₁ # Sβ‚‚. Two facts make it behave like an arithmetic operation:

  • S # SΒ² is homeomorphic to S (adding a sphere does nothing).
  • Ο‡(S₁ # Sβ‚‚) = Ο‡(S₁) + Ο‡(Sβ‚‚) βˆ’ 2, because removing a disk deletes one face and gluing the circles identifies the boundaries with the net loss of 2.

For example, T # T is the double torus with Ο‡ = 0 + 0 βˆ’ 2 = βˆ’2, matching 2 βˆ’ 2g with g = 2.

The theorem

Classification of closed surfaces. Every closed connected surface is homeomorphic to exactly one of

  1. the sphere SΒ²,
  2. a connected sum of g β‰₯ 1 tori T # ... # T (orientable, Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ 2g),
  3. a connected sum of k β‰₯ 1 projective planes β„™Β² # ... # β„™Β² (non-orientable, Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ k).

Each has a normal form as a polygon word:

Surface Word
Sphere a a⁻¹
Genus g orientable a₁ b₁ a₁⁻¹ b₁⁻¹ aβ‚‚ bβ‚‚ a₂⁻¹ b₂⁻¹ ... a_g b_g a_g⁻¹ b_g⁻¹
k projective planes a₁ a₁ aβ‚‚ aβ‚‚ ... a_k a_k

The proof (outlined) first cuts the surface into a polygon with paired edges, then simplifies the word by a short list of moves that do not change the surface: cancel adjacent a a⁻¹ pairs, bring all vertices to a single class, group paired same-sign letters into a a, and rewrite every remaining pair of interleaved pairs as a b a⁻¹ b⁻¹. A final step shows that T # β„™Β² is homeomorphic to β„™Β² # β„™Β² # β„™Β², so mixed words reduce to the third family.

Because T # β„™Β² β‰… β„™Β² # β„™Β² # β„™Β², a surface that is non-orientable never needs a torus in its description. Orientable and non-orientable surfaces form two separate families.

Two invariants decide everything

Given a closed connected surface:

  1. Is it orientable? (Can you choose a consistent side everywhere?)
  2. What is Ο‡?

If orientable, g = (2 βˆ’ Ο‡)/2. If non-orientable, k = 2 βˆ’ Ο‡. The pair determines the surface up to homeomorphism. In particular:

Ο‡ Orientable Non-orientable
2 sphere none
1 none projective plane
0 torus Klein bottle
βˆ’1 none β„™Β² # β„™Β² # β„™Β²
βˆ’2 double torus four crosscaps

An orientable surface always has even Ο‡. A non-orientable surface can have any integer Ο‡ ≀ 1.

Classifying surfaces by code

Combine the two earlier tools: read orientability off the word, compute Ο‡ by gluing corners, then name the surface.

Python A surface classifier for polygon words

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The last two words mix a pair of a-type edges with other kinds of pairs, but the classifier needs only orientability and Ο‡, so they are handled the same way.

Normal forms agree with the formulas

You can confirm the formulas Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ 2g and Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ k by generating the normal-form words and computing Ο‡ by corner gluing.

Python Normal-form words and the formulas 2 βˆ’ 2g and 2 βˆ’ k

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

If every row shows the computed Ο‡ equal to the formula, the counting argument and the normal forms agree.

What the theorem does not cover

The theorem is about closed (compact, no boundary) connected surfaces. With boundary you get more data: the number of boundary circles. A disk, a cylinder and a MΓΆbius band are different (Ο‡ = 1, 0, 0, boundary circles 1, 2, 1, orientable or not). For non-compact surfaces there are far more possibilities. In dimension three and higher no such simple classification exists; in dimension four it is known to be impossible in general. Surfaces are special.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. Which pair of invariants classifies a closed connected surface?

    Closed connected surfaces are determined by whether they are orientable and by Ο‡.
  2. 2. What is the Euler characteristic of the connected sum of a torus and a torus?

    Ο‡(S₁ # Sβ‚‚) = Ο‡(S₁) + Ο‡(Sβ‚‚) βˆ’ 2 = 0 + 0 βˆ’ 2 = βˆ’2, the double torus.
  3. 3. Which surface has Ο‡ = 0 and is non-orientable?

    The Klein bottle is β„™Β² # β„™Β² with Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ 2 = 0. The torus also has Ο‡ = 0 but is orientable.
  4. 4. A closed orientable surface has Ο‡ = βˆ’4. What is its genus?

    Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ 2g gives βˆ’4 = 2 βˆ’ 2g, so g = 3.

Summary

  • A connected sum glues two surfaces along removed disks; Ο‡(S₁ # Sβ‚‚) = Ο‡(S₁) + Ο‡(Sβ‚‚) βˆ’ 2.
  • Every closed connected surface is a sphere, a connected sum of g tori, or a connected sum of k projective planes.
  • Orientability and Ο‡ determine the surface: Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ 2g (orientable) or Ο‡ = 2 βˆ’ k (non-orientable).
  • Normal-form polygon words give the standard representatives.
  • The classification is special to dimension two and to closed surfaces.

Next: Homotopy and the Fundamental Group