Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 12 of 37 ยท Business Objectives and Stakeholders

Stakeholder Conflict and Business Ethics

See why stakeholders' interests clash, how managers resolve conflicts, and what business ethics means, with a worked trade-off example and a decision scoring tool.

Stakeholders often want opposite things. Customers want low prices, while workers want high pay. Owners want high dividends, while the community wants less pollution. When one group gains, another may lose. This is stakeholder conflict, and managers meet it every week.

In this lesson you will see typical conflicts, learn ways to handle them and meet the idea of business ethics: the question of what is right, not only what is legal or profitable.

Common conflicts

Conflict Group A wants Group B wants
Pay versus profit Employees: higher wages Owners: higher profit
Price versus quality Customers: low price Suppliers: higher payment for good materials
Growth versus the neighborhood Managers: a bigger factory Residents: peace and clean air
Short term versus long term Shareholders: dividends now Managers: reinvest to grow later
Speed versus safety Managers: finish quickly Employees: safe procedures
Low costs versus fair supply chains Customers: cheap goods Workers abroad: fair wages

Conflict also appears inside the business. In a large company the owners (shareholders) and the managers may have different aims. Managers may prefer perks and empire-building, while shareholders prefer profit. This is sometimes called the principal-agent problem: managers act as agents for the owners but do not always act in their interest.

Ways to handle conflict

Managers cannot please everyone, but they can reduce harm. Common approaches:

  1. Communicate. Explain decisions, listen to concerns and consult before acting. Many conflicts grow from surprise.
  2. Prioritize. Use the power-interest grid (see stakeholders and their interests) and the firm's objectives to decide whose view counts most.
  3. Compromise. Offer part of what each side wants, such as a modest pay rise plus profit-related bonuses.
  4. Compensate. Offer something in return, for example funding a local playground when a factory expands.
  5. Redesign the plan. Choose quieter machines or build a screen around the site.
  6. Involve stakeholders. Worker representatives, customer panels and community meetings give voices a place in decisions.
  7. Negotiate with representatives. Employees may be represented by a trade union, which bargains for pay and conditions on their behalf.

A sound decision usually weighs short-term gains against long-term relationships. A firm that wins today by ignoring its staff may face turnover and strikes tomorrow.

A worked example

A small furniture maker can choose between two wood suppliers. Supplier A is cheap but cuts forests without replanting. Supplier B costs 8% more and plants new trees. If the firm buys from B, costs rise and profit falls, but the firm gains the support of eco-minded customers and avoids bad publicity. A decision-maker should list who is affected and by how much.

Python Scoring a decision

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The tool does not decide for you. It forces you to state the effects and the importance of each group, which can be argued over. Change the weights and see whether the best option changes.

Business ethics

Ethics are principles about right and wrong behavior. Business ethics concerns how a firm treats employees, customers, suppliers, society and nature. An action can be legal yet unethical. For example, a shop may legally add hidden fees that mislead customers, or a firm may follow the law in a country with weak rules while using methods that would be illegal elsewhere.

Typical ethical issues:

  • Honesty in advertising: not making false claims.
  • Treatment of workers: fair pay, safe conditions, no child labor.
  • Supply chains: making sure that suppliers behave fairly.
  • Product safety: not selling products known to be dangerous.
  • Data and privacy: using customers' information responsibly.
  • Bribery and corruption: paying to win contracts is both unethical and usually illegal.
  • Environmental damage: pollution, waste and use of resources.

Costs and benefits of acting ethically

Possible cost Possible benefit
Higher costs (fair wages, cleaner methods) Better reputation and brand loyalty
Lower short-term profit Happier, more committed employees
Time spent on checks and reports Lower risk of fines and scandals
May lose sales to cheaper rivals Attracts ethical investors and customers

Ethics can lead to higher profit in the long term, but not always. A firm may face a real dilemma where the ethical choice costs money. Managers then have to weigh values and consequences.

Python What does fairer pay cost?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

A 10% wage rise for part of the supply chain adds only a small percentage to the final cost here. Real figures differ, but the exercise shows that ethical choices can be quantified before you decide.

Pressure for ethical behavior

Firms are encouraged to act ethically by laws, pressure groups, media and social networks, investors and customers who choose with their wallets. The next lesson looks at related ideas: social responsibility and sustainability.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which pair shows a typical stakeholder conflict?

    Higher wages reduce profit, so the two groups' interests clash.
  2. 2. Which is a way to resolve conflict?

    Talking early and finding a middle ground reduces harm and builds trust.
  3. 3. Business ethics is mainly about

    Ethics concerns right and wrong behavior, which can go beyond the law.
  4. 4. A firm pays 30% of a 10.00 unit cost in wages. Wages rise 10%. What is the extra cost per unit?

    Wages per unit = 3.00; 10% of 3.00 = 0.30.

Summary

  • Stakeholders often want opposing things, creating conflict.
  • Managers can communicate, prioritize, compromise, compensate and redesign plans.
  • Ethics concerns right and wrong, and an action can be legal but unethical.
  • Ethical behavior can cost money but can bring reputation, loyalty and lower risk.
  • Weighted scoring helps compare options but depends on opinions.

Next: Social Responsibility and Sustainability