Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 22 of 39 · The Ideal Gas and Equipartition

Heat Capacity of Solids: Einstein and Debye Models

Model a crystal as quantum oscillators: derive the Einstein and Debye heat capacities, recover Dulong-Petit at high T and the T-cubed law at low T, and compute both numerically.

At room temperature most simple solids have a molar heat capacity near 3R ≈ 24.9 J/(mol·K), the Dulong-Petit value predicted by equipartition. But as you cool a solid, its heat capacity falls toward zero. Classical physics cannot explain this; quantum statistical mechanics can. This lesson builds the two classic models, Einstein's and Debye's, and compares them numerically.

A solid as a set of oscillators

Atoms in a crystal vibrate about lattice positions. For small vibrations the potential is quadratic, so a crystal of N atoms is equivalent to 3N independent harmonic oscillators (the normal modes). In the classical picture each holds kT, giving U = 3NkT and C = 3Nk. In the quantum picture each oscillator of frequency ν has levels E_n = (n + ½) h ν.

The canonical partition function of one such oscillator is Z = e^(-x/2) / (1 - e^(-x)) with x = hν/(kT), and the mean energy is

Text
⟨E⟩ = hν ( ½ + 1 / (e^x - 1) )

At low T, x is large, ⟨E⟩ hardly moves from the zero-point value, and the oscillator absorbs almost no heat.

The Einstein model (1907)

Einstein assumed all 3N oscillators share one frequency ν_E. Define the Einstein temperature θ_E = h ν_E / k. Differentiating the energy gives

Text
C_E(T) = 3 N k (θ_E/T)² e^(θ_E/T) / (e^(θ_E/T) - 1)²
  • For T ≫ θ_E, C_E → 3Nk: Dulong-Petit.
  • For T ≪ θ_E, C_E falls off exponentially as e^(-θ_E/T).

Einstein's model captured the qualitative freeze-out, one of the earliest quantum successes beyond blackbody radiation. Experiments, though, show a power law at low temperature rather than an exponential. The flaw is the single frequency: real crystals support long-wavelength sound waves with arbitrarily low frequency.

The Debye model (1912)

Debye treated the solid as an elastic continuum with sound waves (phonons), whose frequencies run from 0 up to a maximum ν_D chosen so that the total number of modes is 3N. The Debye temperature is θ_D = h ν_D / k. The result is

Text
C_D(T) = 9 N k (T/θ_D)³ ∫₀^(θ_D/T) x⁴ eˣ / (eˣ - 1)² dx

The integral has no closed form for general T, but two limits are exact:

Limit Result
T ≫ θ_D C → 3Nk (Dulong-Petit)
T ≪ θ_D C → (12π⁴/5) N k (T/θ_D)³ (the Debye T³ law)

The T³ law matches experiment for insulating crystals at low T. Debye temperatures are material properties: roughly 340 K for copper, above 2000 K for diamond, and around 100 K for lead. Treat these as approximate, since the fitted value depends on the temperature range used.

The Debye model is built on a long-wavelength approximation extended to the whole crystal, so it is a very good interpolation, not an exact theory. Real phonon spectra come from lattice dynamics.

Computing the curves

The first example evaluates both models per mole and compares them, with both temperatures set to the same number so only the shape differs. (We use θ = 343 K, a value often quoted for copper's Debye temperature.)

Python Einstein and Debye heat capacity per mole

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

At 300 K the Debye model gives about 94 percent of 3R and Einstein about 90 percent; measured copper is close to 3R (about 24.4 J/(mol·K) at constant pressure), so the two simple models are rough here. At 50 K the Debye value is several times Einstein's because low-frequency phonons remain thermally active.

The T³ law test

On a log-log plot, a power law is a straight line. Plot the Debye heat capacity against T at low temperature, and compare with the exact T³ formula.

Python Debye T-cubed law at low temperature

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The ratio tends to 1 as T falls: with θ = 343 K the T³ formula is already within 0.1 percent at 20 K, while at 40 K it overshoots by several percent.

Beyond lattice vibrations

In metals the conduction electrons add a term linear in T, so measured low-temperature data are fitted as C = γT + A T³. You will derive γ in the Fermi gas lessons of the next chapter section.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. What does the Dulong-Petit law say?

    Equipartition on 3N oscillators with kinetic and potential terms gives 3Nk.
  2. 2. Why does Einstein's model fail at very low temperature?

    A single frequency leads to exponential freeze-out, but real crystals have phonons down to zero frequency and show a T³ law.
  3. 3. The Debye low-temperature law is

    Only phonons with energy below about kT are excited; counting them in three dimensions gives T³.
  4. 4. A solid has Debye temperature 343 K. At 3430 K (ten times higher) its model heat capacity per mole is close to

    T ≫ θ_D recovers the Dulong-Petit limit 3R.

Summary

  • A crystal is 3N quantum oscillators; each freezes out when kT is below its level spacing.
  • Einstein: one frequency, C = 3Nk x² e^x / (e^x - 1)², exponential low-T drop.
  • Debye: a spectrum of sound waves up to ν_D, with the T³ law at low T and 3Nk at high T.
  • Both reduce to Dulong-Petit when T ≫ θ.

Next: Identical Particles and Quantum Statistics