Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 14 of 39 ยท Entanglement

Bell States and Entanglement

Create the four Bell states with H and CNOT, see perfect correlations in every basis, understand what entanglement really means and what it does not, with NumPy simulations.

Entanglement is the feature of quantum mechanics that most defies everyday intuition, and the resource at the heart of quantum communication and quantum speedups. The simplest entangled states, the four Bell states, involve just two qubits. You can create them with two gates and verify their strange properties with a few lines of NumPy.

This lesson shows how to build the Bell states, what makes them special, and how to avoid the most common misconceptions about entanglement.

The four Bell states

Two qubits have four basis states 00, 01, 10, 11. The Bell states are four particular superpositions of them:

  • Phi+ = (|00> + |11>) / sqrt(2)
  • Phi- = (|00> - |11>) / sqrt(2)
  • Psi+ = (|01> + |10>) / sqrt(2)
  • Psi- = (|01> - |10>) / sqrt(2)

They are orthogonal to each other, so they form a complete basis of the two-qubit space, the Bell basis. Every one of them is maximally entangled.

Creating them

Starting from a computational basis state |ab>:

  1. Apply H to the first qubit. This puts it in |+> (if a = 0) or |-> (if a = 1).
  2. Apply CNOT with the first qubit as control and the second as target.

The four starting values give the four Bell states: 00 makes Phi+, 10 makes Phi-, 01 makes Psi+, and 11 makes Psi-. In words: the first bit chooses the sign (phase), the second chooses whether the pair agrees (Phi) or disagrees (Psi).

flowchart LR
    A["|a>"] --> H["H"]
    H --> C["control"]
    B["|b>"] --> T["target (X)"]
    C --> O1["Bell state"]
    T --> O1

A Hadamard followed by a CNOT turns a basis state into a Bell state.

Python Creating all four Bell states

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

What makes them entangled

Remember the product-state test from Multi-Qubit States and the Tensor Product: a two-qubit state is a product exactly when its 2 by 2 amplitude matrix has determinant zero. For Phi+ that matrix is [[1, 0], [0, 1]] / sqrt(2), determinant 1/2, not zero. No amount of searching will find a state a for qubit 0 and b for qubit 1 whose product is Phi+.

The consequences are concrete:

  • Perfect correlation. Measuring both qubits of Phi+ in the 0/1 basis always gives 00 or 11, never a mixed pair, each with probability 1/2.
  • Local randomness. Looked at alone, each qubit's result is a fair coin. No information is carried by one qubit by itself. All the information lives in the relationship between them.
  • Correlation in every basis. If both qubits of Phi+ are measured in the X basis, the results also always agree. Classical shared randomness (two envelopes with matching cards) cannot do that for several bases at once; this is the content of the next-but-one lesson on CHSH and Bell's Inequality.
Python Correlations of Phi+ in the Z and X bases

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

In both bases Phi+ agrees every time while each bit is a fair coin. The product state, by contrast, agrees only about half the time because its two bits are independent.

Reduced states: the part is less than the whole

If you ignore one qubit of an entangled pair, what is the state of the other? The honest answer is that it has no pure state of its own. Its description is a mixed state: with probability 1/2 it is |0> and with probability 1/2 it is |1>, a maximally random coin that sits at the center of the Bloch sphere. We make this precise in the next lesson. The key slogan: in an entangled state the whole is perfectly known, while each part is maximally unknown.

Common misconceptions

"Entanglement lets you send messages faster than light." It does not. The outcome of measuring one half of a Bell pair is random, so the receiver of the other half cannot tell whether anything was done at the far end. Correlations only show up when the two parties later compare notes through an ordinary channel.

  • "Measuring one qubit instantly changes the other, so something travels." The correlation is present in the shared state from the start. What measuring does is update your knowledge. Several interpretations of quantum mechanics disagree about the deeper story, yet all agree about the predicted statistics.
  • "Entanglement is just a hidden classical agreement." Not true; the next lessons show experiments no hidden agreement can reproduce.
  • "Entangled qubits must be near each other." Photons entangled over hundreds of kilometers have been produced. The challenge is keeping the entanglement from decaying.
  • "Entanglement means identical states." Psi- is perfectly anti-correlated, and the sign (phase) differences between Bell states cannot be seen in a single basis.

Why entanglement matters

Entanglement is a resource: it can be generated, used up and measured. With it you can teleport a quantum state with only two classical bits and no direct quantum channel (see Quantum Teleportation), double the classical capacity of a quantum channel (Superdense Coding and No-Cloning), secure communication against eavesdroppers, and, together with interference, achieve algorithmic speedups.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which circuit creates the Bell state (|00> + |11>)/sqrt(2) from |00>?

    H puts qubit 0 in |+>, and CNOT copies the branch onto qubit 1, giving the entangled state.
  2. 2. Measuring both qubits of (|00> + |11>)/sqrt(2) in the Z basis gives:

    Only |00> and |11> have non-zero amplitude, each with probability 1/2.
  3. 3. Can entanglement be used to send messages faster than light?

    The marginal outcomes are fair coins, so no information is transmitted without a classical channel.
  4. 4. What is the state of one qubit of a Bell pair considered alone?

    Ignoring the partner leaves a 50/50 mixture, the center of the Bloch sphere.

Summary

  • The four Bell states are maximally entangled and orthogonal, forming the Bell basis.
  • Hadamard on the first qubit plus CNOT converts a basis state into a Bell state.
  • Their measurements are perfectly correlated while each side alone is random.
  • A non-zero determinant of the amplitude matrix means the state is entangled.
  • Entanglement does not carry messages; it is a resource for protocols and algorithms.

Next: Entanglement Measures and GHZ States