Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 10 of 37 ยท The Writing Process

Proofreading and Feedback

Learn proofreading techniques that catch errors you normally miss, and how to give and receive feedback so that your writing keeps improving.

Proofreading is the final check for small errors: spelling, punctuation, capital letters, missing words and typing slips. It happens after revising, because there is no point fixing the commas in a paragraph you may delete. Feedback is the other half of improvement: a second pair of eyes sees what you cannot.

Why errors hide

When you reread your own work, your brain fills in what you meant, not what you wrote. You see "the the" as "the". That is why proofreading needs special tricks to slow down your eyes.

Proofreading techniques

  1. Take a break. Even ten minutes helps.
  2. Print it or change the font. A different view makes errors visible.
  3. Read aloud, slowly. Point to each word.
  4. Read backwards, sentence by sentence. Starting at the end breaks the flow so you check each sentence alone.
  5. Check one thing at a time. First spelling, then punctuation, then capitals, then names and numbers.
  6. Keep a personal error list. If you often mix up their/there, check for that on purpose.

Common trouble spots

Mix-up Rule of thumb
their / there / they're their = belongs to them; there = place; they're = they are
your / you're your = belongs to you; you're = you are
its / it's its = belongs to it; it's = it is
to / too / two to = direction; too = also or excessive; two = 2
affect / effect affect is usually the verb; effect is usually the noun
then / than then = time; than = comparison
JS Find doubled words

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Some repeats are fine (that that, as in "I know that that is true"), so the tool only gives hints.

JS Check a list of numbers and names

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Getting feedback

Feedback is information from a reader about how your writing works for them. It is not a verdict on you.

How to ask

Give your reader a specific question: "Is my main point clear?" or "Which part confused you?" A reader who knows what to look for gives better help than one told only to "have a look".

How to listen

  • Do not argue or explain while they speak; just take notes.
  • Remember that confusion is useful data: if one reader gets lost, others may too.
  • You decide what to change. Not every suggestion fits your purpose.

How to give feedback

Use the praise, question, suggest method:

  1. Praise: Name something that works and say why. "The opening made me curious."
  2. Question: Ask where you were confused. "What did you mean by 'it' in paragraph two?"
  3. Suggest: Offer one or two ideas. "An example after this claim would help."

Be specific and kind. "It's good" or "It's bad" teaches nothing.

When you give feedback, comment on the writing, not the writer. Say "this paragraph is hard to follow", not "you are bad at paragraphs".

A peer-review sheet

Text
Writer: ________  Reader: ________
1. The main idea is: ______________________
2. My favourite part is: __________________
3. I was confused by: _____________________
4. One thing to add or cut: _______________

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Why is proofreading done after revising?

    Revise first to settle content and structure, then proofread the final text.
  2. 2. Which sentence uses the correct word?

    'They're' means 'they are'.
  3. 3. What does the praise, question, suggest method give a writer?

    It tells the writer what works, what confuses the reader and what to try next.
  4. 4. Which technique helps you notice errors your brain skips?

    Slowing down or reading in an unusual order forces you to see each word.

Summary

  • Proofread last, after revising.
  • Our brains fill in missing or repeated words, so use tricks: break, print, read aloud, read backwards.
  • Check one type of error at a time and learn your common mix-ups.
  • Ask for specific feedback, listen without arguing, and decide what to use.
  • Give feedback with praise, a question and a suggestion.

Next: Paragraph Basics