Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 22 of 37 ยท Essays and Argument

Building an Argument: Claims and Evidence

Learn how to build a convincing argument with claims, evidence and reasoning, choose strong sources, and avoid common logical fallacies.

In everyday speech, an "argument" means a quarrel. In writing, an argument is a reasoned case: you make a claim and give the reader good reasons to accept it. A convincing argument does not shout; it shows its work.

This lesson introduces the three building blocks of an argument, the kinds of evidence you can use, and a few traps in reasoning to avoid.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Most strong arguments contain three parts, often called CER.

  • Claim: a statement you want the reader to accept.
  • Evidence: facts, examples, data, expert opinion or observations that support the claim.
  • Reasoning: the explanation of why the evidence supports the claim.
flowchart LR
    C["Claim"] --- R["Reasoning"]
    E["Evidence"] --- R
    R --> P["Persuaded reader"]

Evidence alone is not enough: the reasoning connects it to the claim.

Here is a short example.

Claim: Our school should add a quiet study room. Evidence: In a survey of 120 students in one class group, 90 said that they cannot concentrate in the library during lunch. Reasoning: If most students cannot concentrate in the current space, a separate quiet room would give them a place where studying is realistic.

(The survey is an invented example for practice. In your own essay, use real data you can name.)

Notice that without the third sentence, the reader has to guess how the survey relates to the room.

Types of evidence

Type What it is Good for Watch out for
Facts and statistics Measurable information Showing scale Old, unsourced or cherry-picked numbers
Examples A specific case Making ideas concrete One example may not be typical
Expert testimony What a qualified person says Adding authority Is the person really an expert on this topic?
Personal experience What you saw or did Opening or illustrating Not proof on its own
Analogy Comparison with a similar case Explaining complex ideas The cases must be truly alike

Use more than one type when you can. A statistic plus an example is stronger than either alone.

Judging a source

Before using evidence, ask:

  1. Who wrote it, and what do they know about the subject?
  2. When was it written? Some topics change fast.
  3. Why was it written? Is the author selling something or pushing a view?
  4. Can it be checked? Does it name its data or sources?

Always say where evidence comes from, for example "according to the national statistics office" or "a 2020 study by researchers at X university". If you cannot name the source, be cautious about using the claim.

Weak claims and strong claims

Strong claims are specific and measured.

  • Weak: "Everyone hates homework."
  • Better: "Many students report that homework takes time from sleep and family."

Words like always, never, everyone and nobody invite the reader to find one exception. Words like often, many, usually and tends to are safer when the evidence does not cover everything.

Logical fallacies to avoid

A fallacy is an error in reasoning that makes an argument look stronger than it is. Learn to spot a few common ones, both in your own writing and in what you read.

  • Hasty generalization: drawing a broad conclusion from too few cases. "My two cousins failed the test, so the test is unfair."
  • Ad hominem: attacking the person instead of the idea. "You cannot trust her view on diets; she is not even slim."
  • Straw man: misrepresenting the other side so it is easy to knock down.
  • False dilemma: claiming there are only two options when there are more. "Either we ban phones completely or students will never learn."
  • Slippery slope: claiming that one small step will inevitably lead to disaster, without evidence.
  • Appeal to popularity: claiming something is true because many people believe it.
  • Circular reasoning: using the claim as its own proof. "The rule is fair because it is the rule."

When you review your draft, underline each claim and write the evidence in the margin. If a claim has no evidence beside it, either find some or remove the claim.

Appeals: logos, ethos, pathos

Classical rhetoric names three ways to persuade:

  • Logos: appeal to logic and evidence.
  • Ethos: appeal to credibility and trust (the writer or source seems fair and knowledgeable).
  • Pathos: appeal to emotion.

A good argument leans mainly on logos, builds ethos through fairness and accuracy, and uses pathos carefully so that feeling supports reason instead of replacing it.

Practice with code

This stand-in builds a CER paragraph from three parts. It shows the structure; the quality of the sentences is up to you.

JS CER paragraph builder

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The next example scans text for absolute words that often signal an overstated claim.

JS Overstatement finder

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What does the 'reasoning' part of an argument do?

    Reasoning is the link between evidence and claim; without it the reader must guess.
  2. 2. Which is an example of a hasty generalization?

    A conclusion based on too few cases is a hasty generalization.
  3. 3. Which source question helps you judge trustworthiness?

    Knowing who wrote a source and their purpose helps you decide how far to trust it.
  4. 4. Claiming there are only two options when more exist is called a...

    A false dilemma ignores other possible options.

Summary

  • An argument is a claim supported by evidence and reasoning.
  • Use several types of evidence and judge each source for author, date, purpose and checkability.
  • Prefer specific, measured claims over absolute ones.
  • Learn common fallacies so you can avoid them and spot them.
  • Logos, ethos and pathos are three ways to persuade; rely mainly on logic.

Next: Counterarguments and Rebuttals