Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 34 of 37 ยท Cosmology

Dark Matter and Dark Energy

Discover the evidence for dark matter and dark energy, the 5/27/68 split of the universe, and simulate how expansion and age depend on what fills space.

Everything you have seen so far, stars, planets, gas and dust, adds up to only about 5% of the universe. About 27% is dark matter, which pulls like matter but does not shine. The remaining 68% is dark energy, which acts to speed up the expansion of space. These are the most important open puzzles in astronomy. This lesson explains the evidence and what it means for the universe's future.

Dark matter

The evidence

  1. Galaxy clusters. In the 1930s Fritz Zwicky found that galaxies in the Coma Cluster moved too fast to be held by visible matter alone.
  2. Rotation curves. Vera Rubin measured spiral galaxies in the 1970s and found their outer stars orbit as fast as inner ones (see the Milky Way). A halo of unseen mass is needed.
  3. Gravitational lensing. Mass bends light. The amount of bending by galaxy clusters is much larger than visible mass would cause.
  4. The Bullet Cluster. Two clusters collided. The hot gas (most of the visible matter) was slowed by the collision, but lensing shows that most of the mass kept going, separated from the gas. This is strong evidence that the mass is in a form that does not collide with itself.
  5. The CMB and structure growth. Models of the cosmic microwave background ripples and of galaxy formation only work with plenty of non-interacting matter.

What is it?

Nobody knows. Dark matter does not seem to emit, absorb or reflect light. Candidates include new particles (such as WIMPs or axions), which laboratories have been trying to detect for decades without success. Ordinary matter that is merely faint (dim stars, black holes) cannot explain it: the amount of ordinary matter is limited by the Big Bang nucleosynthesis and CMB measurements.

Some scientists have proposed that gravity itself behaves differently on galactic scales (modified gravity theories). Such ideas have trouble explaining all the evidence at once, especially the Bullet Cluster and the CMB, so most astronomers favor dark matter. But the nature of dark matter is unknown.

Dark energy

For decades cosmologists expected gravity to slow the expansion over time. In 1998 two teams measuring distant Type Ia supernovae (see measuring cosmic distances) found the opposite: distant supernovae were fainter than expected, meaning that they are farther away, and so the expansion has been speeding up. Saul Perlmutter, Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess shared the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics for this discovery.

The name dark energy is a placeholder for whatever causes the acceleration. The simplest explanation is a constant energy density of empty space, the cosmological constant (ฮ›), which Einstein had included in his equations in 1917 and later regretted. Other ideas allow dark energy to change over time. It is a very active research topic.

The cosmic budget

Combined measurements (the Planck satellite results, for example) give approximately:

Component Share of the universe's total energy
Ordinary matter (atoms) about 5%
Dark matter about 27%
Dark energy about 68%

The critical density is the density of a flat universe: ฯ_c = 3 Hโ‚€ยฒ / (8 ฯ€ G). Only about 5% of it is ordinary matter.

Python Critical density and the cosmic budget

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Average ordinary matter density is a fraction of a single hydrogen atom per cubic meter. Space is mostly empty.

Expansion and the fate of the universe

Expansion is described by the scale factor a(t), which is 1 today and was smaller in the past. For a flat universe with matter (ฮฉ_m) and a cosmological constant (ฮฉ_ฮ›), the expansion rate is H(a) = Hโ‚€ โˆš(ฮฉ_m / aยณ + ฮฉ_ฮ›), ignoring radiation. Taking H = (da/dt)/a, we can integrate to find the time, for example the age: t = โˆซ da / (a H(a)).

Python Age of the universe and future expansion

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

This is a simplified model: it ignores radiation and uses one set of parameters. It does show the main point. With dark energy, the scale factor grows faster and faster. The calculated age is close to the measured 13.8 billion years, and the matter-only universe grows more slowly and would be younger.

Possible fates

If dark energy remains a constant, the expansion will accelerate forever. Galaxies beyond our Local Group will move out of reach, stars will use up their fuel, and the universe will become cold and dark, the Big Freeze (or "heat death"). If dark energy strengthens it could tear structures apart (a "Big Rip"); if it reverses, a "Big Crunch" is possible. Current data favor the Big Freeze, but we do not know what dark energy really is, so the long-term future is still uncertain.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which observation showed that the expansion of the universe is accelerating?

    In 1998, supernova surveys found the supernovae were farther than a decelerating universe would put them.
  2. 2. What does the Bullet Cluster suggest?

    Lensing shows the mass peaks are separated from the X-ray gas, consistent with collisionless dark matter.
  3. 3. Roughly what fraction of the universe's energy content is ordinary matter?

    About 5% is atoms, about 27% dark matter and about 68% dark energy.
  4. 4. What is the simplest candidate for dark energy?

    A cosmological constant ฮ› fits current data well, though its origin is unexplained.

Summary

  • Dark matter (about 27%) is inferred from galaxy motions, lensing, clusters and the CMB; its nature is unknown.
  • Dark energy (about 68%) makes the expansion accelerate, discovered with supernovae in 1998.
  • Ordinary matter is only about 5% of the total.
  • If dark energy is constant, the universe will expand forever and grow cold and dark.

Next: Practice: Stellar Calculations