Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 2 of 39 ยท Getting Started

Sources and Evidence

Learn the difference between primary and secondary sources, how to judge reliability and bias, and practice with a simple source-checking tool.

Historians cannot travel back in time. All they have are sources: the things that survive from the past and the things later people wrote about it. Learning to read sources critically is the single most useful skill in this course. It also helps outside school, whenever you meet a claim online or in the news.

Primary and secondary sources

A primary source comes from the time being studied. It was made by someone who lived through the events or by a person of that period. Examples include letters, diaries, laws, coins, tools, buildings, paintings, treaties and photographs.

A secondary source is made later, by someone who studied the primary sources. A modern textbook about ancient Egypt is a secondary source. So is a documentary.

Type Made when? Examples
Primary During the period A clay tablet, a soldier's letter, a law code
Secondary Later, about the period A textbook, a museum guide, a biography

The same object can be primary or secondary depending on your question. A history book written in 1850 is a secondary source about Rome, but a primary source about how people in 1850 thought about Rome.

Written and unwritten sources

Not every source is a text. Archaeology recovers objects, bones, seeds and the remains of buildings. For prehistory, such objects are the only evidence. Even in literate societies, most people did not write. Their lives show up in tombs, rubbish heaps, household goods and the layout of villages.

Other kinds of evidence include oral history (stories passed down by speaking, important in many African and Pacific societies), art, maps and language itself. Words borrowed from one language into another show contact between peoples.

Questions to ask of any source

Use the following checklist. Historians often shorten it to a few key points: origin, purpose, content and reliability.

  1. Who made it? Their role, class, country and beliefs shape what they say.
  2. When and where? Was the author an eyewitness, or writing decades later?
  3. Why was it made? To inform, to persuade, to record taxes, to boast?
  4. Who was the audience? A private diary differs from a public speech.
  5. What does it leave out? Silence can be as revealing as statements.
  6. Can it be checked against other sources? Agreement between independent sources is strong evidence.

Bias is not the same as uselessness

A biased source favors one side. A royal inscription that says a king "never lost a battle" is almost certainly boasting. It still tells you what that king wanted people to believe, and which victories he thought worth recording.

Think of a source as a window with a tinted pane. You cannot remove the tint, but if you know its color you can still see through it.

Corroboration

To corroborate is to confirm with other evidence. When a written account of a harvest failure matches tree-ring evidence of drought, both gain strength. When two sources disagree, the historian does not just pick one. They ask why they differ.

flowchart TD
  A["Find a source"] --> B["Ask who, when, why"]
  B --> C["Compare with other sources"]
  C --> D{"Do they agree?"}
  D -->|"Yes"| E["Stronger claim"]
  D -->|"No"| F["Ask why they differ"]

A basic evidence-checking loop.

Try it: a source checklist

This is a tiny tool that scores a source against the checklist. It is a teaching aid, not a real measure of truth: it counts how many questions you can answer well.

JS Source scorecard

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Try it: separating primary from secondary

A list of items can be sorted by the year they were made compared with the period they are about.

JS Primary or secondary?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The result depends on the period you choose, which is exactly the point of the tip above.

A worked example

Suppose two sources describe a battle. A general's report says the enemy fled in terror. A farmer's letter says the army trampled his crops and stole his grain. Neither is false, but they show different sides. The general wants praise; the farmer wants compensation. Together they build a fuller picture than either alone.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which is a primary source about the American Revolution?

    A letter written at the time is a primary source. The others were made later.
  2. 2. What does corroboration mean?

    To corroborate is to support a claim using other independent evidence.
  3. 3. A king's monument says he won every battle. What is the best response?

    Biased sources are still useful; you ask why they were made and compare them with other evidence.
  4. 4. Which source type is the main evidence for prehistory?

    Before writing, archaeology is the main way we learn about people.

Summary

  • Primary sources come from the period; secondary sources are made later by people who studied it.
  • Evidence includes texts, objects, buildings, art, oral history and language.
  • Ask who made a source, when, why, for whom and what it leaves out.
  • Bias does not make a source worthless; it tells you what to question.
  • Corroboration with other sources makes a claim stronger.

Next: Timelines and Dating