Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 6 of 38 ยท Principles and WCAG

WCAG Versions and Conformance Levels

Understand how WCAG is structured, the differences between versions 2.0, 2.1 and 2.2, what conformance levels A, AA and AAA mean, and which level to target.

WCAG is the international standard for web accessibility, published by the W3C's Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). Laws, contracts and procurement rules point to it, so you should know how it is organised. This lesson explains the versions, the structure of the document and the conformance levels, and ends with a practical answer to "which level should we target?".

A short history

  • WCAG 1.0 (1999) was technology-specific and is obsolete.
  • WCAG 2.0 (2008, ISO standard 40500) introduced the POUR principles and testable success criteria. It is still referenced by many laws.
  • WCAG 2.1 (2018) added criteria for mobile, low vision and cognitive needs.
  • WCAG 2.2 (2023) added nine more criteria and removed one obsolete one (4.1.1 Parsing). It is the current recommendation.
  • WCAG 3.0 is a long-running draft with a different scoring model. It is not a replacement you can adopt today.

Each version is backwards compatible: a page that meets 2.2 also meets 2.1 and 2.0 (apart from the removed parsing criterion, which modern browsers made moot). So aiming at the newest version covers the older ones.

How WCAG is structured

The document has several layers:

  1. Principles: the four POUR ideas.
  2. Guidelines: thirteen goals, such as 1.1 Text Alternatives or 2.4 Navigable.
  3. Success criteria: the testable rules, such as 1.4.3 Contrast (Minimum). Each has a level.
  4. Techniques: sufficient and advisory ways to meet a criterion, and documented failures. Techniques are informative, so you can meet a criterion another way.

A criterion number tells you where it lives: 1.4.3 is principle 1 (Perceivable), guideline 4 (Distinguishable), criterion 3.

flowchart TD
  P["Principle: 1 Perceivable"] --> G["Guideline: 1.4 Distinguishable"]
  G --> S["Success criterion: 1.4.3 Contrast (Minimum), Level AA"]
  S --> T["Techniques: G18, G145, F24 ..."]

Four layers from idea to test.

Conformance levels

Every success criterion is labelled A, AA or AAA:

  • Level A is the minimum. Failing one of these makes content unusable for some groups. Examples: text alternatives, keyboard access, no keyboard trap.
  • Level AA removes the biggest remaining barriers. It includes contrast of 4.5:1, text resize, visible focus, consistent navigation and error suggestions.
  • Level AAA is the highest and most specific. Examples: contrast of 7:1, sign language for media, reading level.

To claim conformance to a level, a page must meet all criteria at that level and the levels below. Conforming to AA means meeting all A and all AA criteria.

The three levels

Level A The essential minimum
Level AA The usual target
Level AAA Enhanced, not always possible

AA requires A plus AA.

1 / 2

Which level should you target?

Almost every law and policy asks for WCAG 2.1 or 2.2 Level AA. That is the practical goal. Level AAA is not recommended as a blanket requirement because some criteria cannot be met for all content, but meeting individual AAA criteria where they are cheap, such as clear link purpose or a 7:1 contrast for body text, is a good idea.

Conformance also has requirements beyond individual criteria:

  • Full pages: conformance applies to whole pages, not parts of one.
  • Complete processes: a checkout must conform from first step to last.
  • Only accessibility-supported ways of using technologies: techniques must work with real assistive technology.
  • Non-interference: anything that breaks the rules must not block users, such as a keyboard trap.

Try it: classify a few criteria

Criteria and their levels

Notice how choosing AA shows A as well, which mirrors how conformance works: each level includes the ones beneath it.

Reading a success criterion

Each criterion page in the spec is formatted the same way: the normative requirement, an Intent section explaining why it exists, Benefits, Examples, and lists of Sufficient Techniques and Failures. When a rule seems vague, read the "Understanding" document for it first. It is written for developers and gives plain examples.

Two words matter. Must and should are not used in the criterion text itself. The text states a testable condition, and everything under it is guidance. Also check the glossary: terms like "programmatically determined" and "accessible name" have exact meanings.

Accessibility statements and the rest of the family

WCAG is one of three related documents. ATAG covers authoring tools such as CMSs, and UAAG covers browsers and media players. Alongside them sits WAI-ARIA, the roles and attributes specification you will meet in the next chapter.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which WCAG version added nine new criteria in 2023?

    WCAG 2.2 added nine criteria, such as Focus Not Obscured and Target Size (Minimum).
  2. 2. What does conforming to Level AA require?

    Levels are cumulative, so AA conformance includes every Level A criterion too.
  3. 3. What does the number 2.4.7 tell you?

    Criterion numbers follow principle.guideline.criterion, so 2.4.7 is under Operable, Navigable.
  4. 4. Are the techniques in WCAG mandatory?

    Techniques are ways to succeed, not the rules. The success criteria are the normative part.

Summary

  • WCAG 2.2 is the current version and is backwards compatible with 2.1 and 2.0.
  • The document runs from principles to guidelines to success criteria to techniques.
  • Levels A, AA and AAA are cumulative, and Level AA is the practical target.
  • Conformance applies to whole pages and complete processes.
  • Use the Understanding documents when a criterion is unclear.

Next: A Tour of the Success Criteria