Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 30 of 37 · The Riemann Integral

Improper Integrals and Lebesgue's Criterion

Extend the Riemann integral to unbounded intervals and functions with improper integrals, test convergence of p-integrals, and learn Lebesgue's criterion with Thomae's function.

The Riemann integral is defined only for bounded functions on closed bounded intervals. Many useful integrals break one of these rules: ∫₀¹ x^{-1/2} dx (unbounded function) and ∫₁^∞ x^{-2} dx (infinite interval). Improper integrals extend the definition with a limit. In the second half of this lesson we answer the opposite question: exactly which bounded functions are Riemann integrable?

Improper integrals

Infinite interval. If f is integrable on [a, R] for every R > a, define

Text
∫ₐ^∞ f = lim_{R → ∞} ∫ₐᴿ f

when the limit exists as a finite number (the integral converges); otherwise it diverges.

Unbounded at an endpoint. If f is integrable on [a + η, b] for every small η > 0 but unbounded near a, define ∫ₐᵇ f = lim_{η → 0+} ∫_{a+η}ᵇ f.

If the bad point is inside the interval, split there and require both pieces to converge separately. (Taking the limit symmetrically around the point gives a weaker "principal value" that is a different notion.)

The p-integrals

For p > 0:

Text
∫₁^∞ x^{-p} dx converges  ⇔  p > 1,        ∫₀¹ x^{-p} dx converges  ⇔  p < 1.

Proof of the first. For p ≠ 1, ∫₁ᴿ x^{-p} dx = (R^{1-p} - 1)/(1 - p). If p > 1, this tends to 1/(p - 1). If p < 1, it tends to +∞. For p = 1, ∫₁ᴿ dx/x = ln R → ∞. The second statement is proved with ∫_η¹ x^{-p} dx = (1 - η^{1-p})/(1 - p). ∎

Python Partial integrals of p-integrals

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The values level off for p = 2 on [1, ∞) (limit 1) and for p = 0.5 on (0, 1] (limit 2); they grow without bound in the other cases.

Comparison test

If 0 ≤ f ≤ g on [a, ∞) and ∫ g converges, then ∫ f converges; if ∫ f diverges, so does ∫ g. Example: 1/(1 + x²) ≤ 1/x² for x ≥ 1, so ∫₁^∞ dx/(1 + x²) converges. Indeed its value is π/4, since an antiderivative is arctan x.

Python Comparison test in numbers

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Lebesgue's criterion

Which bounded functions on [a, b] are Riemann integrable? The complete answer uses the idea of a set of measure zero: a set E ⊂ ℝ has measure zero if, for every ε > 0, E can be covered by countably many open intervals whose total length is less than ε. Every countable set (like ℚ) has measure zero.

Theorem (Lebesgue's criterion). A bounded function f : [a, b] → ℝ is Riemann integrable if and only if the set of points where f is discontinuous has measure zero.

We will not prove it here, but it explains our earlier examples:

  • Dirichlet function: discontinuous at every point, not measure zero, not integrable.
  • Monotone functions: discontinuities are countable, so measure zero, so integrable.
  • Continuous functions and functions with finitely many jumps: integrable.

Thomae's function is t(x) = 1/q if x = p/q in lowest terms (with q ≥ 1), and t(x) = 0 if x is irrational. It is continuous at every irrational point and discontinuous at every rational point. The discontinuity set ℚ ∩ [0, 1] is countable, so measure zero; thus t is Riemann integrable, with ∫₀¹ t = 0.

Why continuity at irrationals: given ε > 0, only finitely many rationals in [0, 1] have denominator q ≤ 1/ε, so a small neighborhood of an irrational x avoids them all and t < ε there.

Python Thomae's function: how few values are large

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The last estimate is a heuristic illustration: it ignores rationals with larger denominators (whose values are below 1/60), so the printed numbers are slightly below the true upper sums, which also tend to 0.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. For which p does the integral of x^(-p) over [1, infinity) converge?

    For p > 1 the partial integrals tend to 1/(p-1); for p at most 1 they grow without bound.
  2. 2. For which p does the integral of x^(-p) over (0, 1] converge?

    Near 0 the function x^(-p) is integrable only when the singularity is milder than 1/x.
  3. 3. Lebesgue's criterion says a bounded f is Riemann integrable iff:

    Continuity almost everywhere, in the measure-zero sense, is exactly what is needed.
  4. 4. Thomae's function is:

    Its discontinuities are the rationals, a countable set of measure zero, so Lebesgue's criterion gives integrability.

Summary

  • Improper integrals are limits of proper integrals over expanding or shrinking intervals; they converge when the limit is finite.
  • ∫₁^∞ x^{-p} converges iff p > 1; ∫₀¹ x^{-p} converges iff p < 1. The comparison test extends this to other functions.
  • Lebesgue's criterion: a bounded function is Riemann integrable iff its discontinuity set has measure zero.
  • Thomae's function is discontinuous at every rational and yet integrable with integral 0.

Next: Pointwise and Uniform Convergence