Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 23 of 36 ยท Debt and Loans

Leasing, Buying and Big Purchases

Learn how to compare leasing, financing and paying cash for big purchases such as a car, using total cost of ownership and depreciation.

Sooner or later you will make a big purchase: a car, a computer for work, furniture, maybe a home. For each, there are usually three ways to get it: pay cash, borrow to buy (finance), or lease (rent it for a fixed period). Salespeople often talk only about the monthly payment. A smarter way to decide is to compare the total cost over the time you will really use the item.

This lesson gives you the vocabulary and a calculator that does the comparison for you.

Key ideas

  • Depreciation: the loss of value of an item over time. A new car usually loses a large share of its value in the first few years; a computer loses value even faster.
  • Total cost of ownership (TCO): everything you pay over the time you own the item: purchase price, interest, insurance, fuel, repairs, taxes, minus what you can sell it for at the end.
  • Lease: you pay to use the item for a fixed term, then return it. You do not own it at the end (unless there is a buy-out option). Leases often limit usage, such as a maximum distance per year, and charge for damage.
  • Residual value: what the item is expected to be worth at the end of a lease or at resale.
  • Opportunity cost: what your money could have earned elsewhere if you had not spent it.

Three ways to get it

Way Upfront cost At the end Good when
Pay cash Highest You own it and can sell it You have savings beyond your emergency fund
Finance (loan) Deposit plus payments You own it after the last payment You want to own it but do not have the cash
Lease Often small You return it, own nothing You want a new item every few years and stay within limits

Notice that none of these is always best. Leasing often has lower monthly payments, but you pay again and again if you always lease. Financing builds ownership, but you carry the interest and the risk of the item losing value.

Before any big purchase, wait a few days. Impulse is the most expensive feature. Also check the "need vs want" list in your budget, and make sure the payment fits without using your emergency fund.

Comparing total cost

Here is the comparison logic. For buying with a loan, TCO is deposit + all payments โˆ’ resale value + running costs. For leasing, it is any upfront fee + all lease payments + running costs (and any end-of-lease charges).

The program below is a calculator with invented numbers. It compares keeping an item bought with a loan against leasing, over the same number of years.

Python Buy with a loan or lease?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Try changing the resale value. If the item holds its value well, buying looks better. If it loses value quickly, leasing may be cheaper. The result depends on your assumptions, so be honest about them.

The long game: owning for longer

The biggest savings often come from keeping an item for a long time. A car that you keep for ten years spreads its cost over more years than one you replace every three.

Python Cost per year by years owned

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Notice how the yearly cost falls as you keep the item longer, but repairs rise. The best time to replace something is often when its yearly cost starts to rise again.

A purchase checklist

  1. Do I need it, and what is the cheapest option that does the job?
  2. Is there a good used option? Used items skip the fastest depreciation.
  3. What is the total cost over the time I will really use it?
  4. Can I pay cash from savings without touching my emergency fund?
  5. If I borrow, is the rate low and the term short?
  6. What are the hidden costs (insurance, fuel, repairs, mileage limits, fees)?

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What is depreciation?

    Depreciation is the decrease in value as an item ages or is used.
  2. 2. At the end of a normal lease you

    A lease is a long rental. You usually return the item unless there is a buy-out option.
  3. 3. Total cost of ownership includes

    TCO adds up everything you pay and subtracts what you recover when you sell.
  4. 4. Why is comparing only the monthly payment risky?

    A lower payment may mean more months, fees or no ownership, so the total can be higher.

Summary

  • You can pay cash, finance with a loan, or lease; none is always best.
  • Compare total cost of ownership over the time you will actually use the item.
  • Depreciation, interest, running costs and resale value decide the answer.
  • Keeping items longer usually lowers the yearly cost until repairs rise.
  • Wait before big purchases and keep your emergency fund intact.

Next: Why Invest? Risk and Return