Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 32 of 38 ยท Testing and Tooling

SAST, DAST, SCA and IAST Compared

Compare static, dynamic, composition and interactive application security testing, learn what each finds and misses, and how to combine them in a CI pipeline.

Security testing comes in several flavors, and the acronyms blur together. Each approach looks at the application from a different angle, so each finds different problems and misses others. This lesson explains the four main automated types, where they fit in a pipeline, and how to avoid drowning in false alarms.

They support the process described in The Secure Development Lifecycle. The code samples are simplified stand-ins that run in your browser and do not scan real systems.

The four types

SAST: Static Application Security Testing. Analyzes source code, bytecode or binaries without running the app. It looks for dangerous patterns, such as user input flowing into an SQL query (taint analysis), hard-coded secrets or weak crypto. Strength: early, pinpoints the line of code, covers code paths that are rarely executed. Weakness: false positives, no awareness of runtime configuration, language-specific.

DAST: Dynamic Application Security Testing. Tests the running application from outside, like an attacker with no source code: sends crafted requests and inspects responses. Strength: language-independent, finds real exploitable behavior and misconfiguration (headers, exposed paths, TLS). Weakness: later in the cycle, limited coverage of what it can reach, cannot point at the exact line.

SCA: Software Composition Analysis. Inventories third-party libraries and matches them with vulnerability data and licenses (see Dependency Scanning and SBOMs). Strength: fast, precise for known flaws. Weakness: knows nothing about flaws in your own code.

IAST: Interactive Application Security Testing. An agent inside the running app observes data flow and calls while tests (or QA) exercise the app. Strength: low false positives and exact stack traces. Weakness: needs an agent and good test coverage, language support varies, adds overhead.

Four angles on the same app

SAST Reads the code.
DAST Attacks the running app.
SCA Checks the libraries.
IAST Watches from inside.

Use them together, not instead of each other.

1 / 2

Where they run in a pipeline

flowchart LR
    C["Commit / PR"] --> S1["Secret scan + SAST"]
    S1 --> S2["SCA + license check"]
    S2 --> B["Build, unit tests"]
    B --> D["Deploy to staging"]
    D --> S3["DAST + IAST during integration tests"]
    S3 --> P["Release gate"]

Fast checks run on every pull request; slower dynamic tests run on staging.

What none of them find well

Automated tools struggle with business logic and access control: "can user A open user B's invoice?", "can I reuse a coupon?", "can I skip the payment step?" The tool does not know your rules. These need threat modeling, requirements-driven tests and skilled manual testing. Treat tools as a floor, not a ceiling.

A toy SAST rule: taint tracking

Real SAST engines build a model of the code. The stand-in below shows the core idea on a three-line program: mark values from user input as tainted, propagate them through assignments, and report when a tainted value reaches a sink such as an SQL execution.

Python A toy taint analyzer

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The query built from name is reported; the parameterized call using age is not. Real tools handle functions, classes and frameworks, which is why they produce both more findings and more noise.

A toy DAST check: response headers

A dynamic scanner inspects responses. This stand-in checks a fictional response (no network) for missing defensive headers.

Python Check a sample response for security headers

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Reducing noise

  • Tune rules to your stack; disable rules that never apply, with a recorded reason.
  • Triage new findings quickly; a backlog of 5,000 unreviewed alerts trains everyone to ignore alerts.
  • Fail the build only on high-confidence, high-severity findings; report the rest.
  • Baseline old findings so pull requests show only new issues, and schedule the cleanup.
  • Fix classes of problems (use a parameterized query helper) rather than single instances.
  • Verify with a test: after fixing a finding, add a regression test.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which testing type needs the application to be running and works without source code?

    DAST sends requests to the running app and observes responses, like an outside attacker.
  2. 2. Which type best finds a known vulnerability in a third-party library?

    Software composition analysis matches your component list against advisory data.
  3. 3. What do automated tools find least well?

    Tools do not know your business rules, so logic and authorization flaws need requirements-based tests and human review.
  4. 4. What is a good way to keep a SAST tool useful over time?

    Noise management keeps people paying attention to real findings.

Summary

  • SAST reads code, DAST attacks the running app, SCA checks libraries, IAST observes from inside.
  • Combine them in the pipeline: fast checks on pull requests, dynamic tests on staging.
  • Tools miss logic and access control flaws; keep manual review and requirement-based tests.
  • Tune, baseline and triage to keep findings actionable.

Next: Authorized Testing and Scoping