Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 30 of 40 ยท Deployment and Delivery

Jenkins vs GitHub Actions, GitLab CI and Others

Compare Jenkins with GitHub Actions and GitLab CI: model, hosting, cost, security and plugins, how to translate a Jenkinsfile, and how to choose a tool.

Jenkins is not the only way to run a pipeline. GitHub Actions, GitLab CI/CD, CircleCI, Azure Pipelines, Buildkite, Jenkins' younger rivals and cloud-native tools such as Tekton and Argo all solve the same core problem: run a defined set of steps on every change. Their concepts overlap a lot, which is good news. What you learned about stages, agents, triggers, credentials and artifacts transfers almost one-to-one.

This lesson compares the main options honestly, shows how a Jenkinsfile maps onto GitHub Actions, and gives you a way to choose. The tools themselves cannot run on this site, so the YAML and Groovy are read-only, and the runnable examples are Node stand-ins that map pipeline concepts and score a decision.

Same problem, different shapes

Jenkins You host it. Maximum flexibility.
GitHub Actions Built into GitHub. Workflows in YAML.
GitLab CI Built into GitLab. One .gitlab-ci.yml.
Others CircleCI, Azure Pipelines, Buildkite...
1 / 2

The same ideas under different names

Every tool has the same skeleton: something triggers a run, the run has steps grouped into stages or jobs, those execute on a runner or agent, they use secrets, and they produce artifacts and a result. The vocabulary is the only big change:

Concept Jenkins GitHub Actions GitLab CI
Pipeline file Jenkinsfile .github/workflows/*.yml .gitlab-ci.yml
Grouping stage job stage containing jobs
Machine that runs it agent (label) runner (runs-on) runner (tags)
Reusable pieces shared library reusable workflow, action include, templates
Secrets credentials secrets (repo, org) CI/CD variables (masked)
Matrix matrix directive strategy.matrix parallel: matrix
Manual gate input step environment with required reviewers when: manual
Extensions plugins marketplace actions templates, integrations

How they differ in practice

Who runs it

Jenkins is self-hosted software. You provide the controller and agents, patch Java and plugins, back it up (see Backup, Monitoring and Troubleshooting) and scale it. GitHub Actions and GitLab CI are offered as hosted services tied to a code host, with hosted runners you do not manage, and the option to add your own self-hosted runners. GitLab itself can also be self-managed.

Flexibility and ecosystem

Jenkins has a huge plugin ecosystem and can model almost any workflow, including odd ones: old operating systems, special hardware, tightly controlled networks, very long or very large builds. The price is that you assemble and maintain the pieces. Actions and GitLab CI offer far less to administer and a smoother start, and their reusable building blocks (actions, templates) are easy to share, but they assume you live on that platform.

Cost

Hosted tools usually charge by build minutes beyond a free allowance, with different multipliers per operating system or machine size. Jenkins has no license fee, but you pay for machines and, importantly, people's time to run it. Self-hosted runners for Actions or GitLab shift compute cost to you while keeping the orchestration managed. Check the current pricing pages before deciding, because they change.

Security model

With Jenkins you own the whole attack surface: the controller's patching, plugin vulnerabilities, who can edit pipelines, and agent isolation (see Security, Users and Authorization). In hosted tools, the vendor secures the platform, and you secure your workflows: be careful with untrusted pull requests, use least-privilege tokens and pin third-party actions to a commit. In both worlds, the rule is the same: code from a pull request is untrusted.

Where the pipeline lives

All three keep the pipeline in the repository. A real difference is coupling. GitHub Actions and GitLab CI are tightly integrated with their own pull requests, checks, environments and package registries. Jenkins is neutral: it works with GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket and plain Git, which suits companies with mixed code hosts.

Translating a Jenkinsfile to GitHub Actions

Here is a small Jenkinsfile (read-only):

GROOVY
pipeline {
  agent { label 'linux' }
  environment { CI = 'true' }
  stages {
    stage('Install') {
      steps { sh 'npm ci' }
    }
    stage('Test') {
      steps { sh 'npm test' }
    }
    stage('Package') {
      steps {
        sh 'npm pack'
        archiveArtifacts artifacts: '*.tgz', fingerprint: true
      }
    }
  }
  post {
    failure { echo 'Build failed' }
  }
}

A reasonable GitHub Actions workflow with the same behavior (read-only):

YAML
name: ci
on:
  push:
    branches: [main]
  pull_request:

jobs:
  build:
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    env:
      CI: "true"
    steps:
      - uses: actions/checkout@v4
      - uses: actions/setup-node@v4
        with:
          node-version: 22
      - run: npm ci
      - run: npm test
      - run: npm pack
      - uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4
        with:
          name: package
          path: "*.tgz"
      - name: Report failure
        if: failure()
        run: echo "Build failed"

The mapping is mechanical, but notice the differences. Jenkins checks out the code for you in a pipeline from SCM, while Actions needs an explicit checkout step. Tools such as Node come from a Jenkins tools block or the agent image, and from setup-node in Actions. Jenkins' post { failure } becomes a step guarded by if: failure(). For the Actions side in depth, see GitHub Actions in the Git tutorial.

Things that do not translate one-to-one deserve a plan before migrating:

  • Plugin features with no equivalent action, such as a special deployment plugin.
  • Shared libraries with custom steps: rewrite as reusable workflows, composite actions or scripts.
  • Groovy logic in scripted pipelines: move it into shell or a small script file that works anywhere.
  • Agent environments: hand-built agents with many tools need a container image or setup steps.
  • Credentials and approvals: recreate them as secrets and environment protection rules.

The least risky migration is gradual: move one repository at a time, keep the same build scripts (./build.sh) callable from both systems, and compare results.

Hybrid setups

You do not have to choose one tool for everything. Real organizations often run:

  • GitHub Actions for quick checks on pull requests, and Jenkins for heavy, long, internal or hardware-bound pipelines.
  • A hosted CI for building and a separate deployment tool (Argo CD, Spinnaker, a Jenkins job) for releases.
  • Self-hosted runners for hosted CI when builds need private networks or special machines.

The trick that makes this work is keeping logic in scripts that live in the repository (make test, ./ci/build.sh) and letting each CI tool be a thin caller. Then switching tools means rewriting a few lines of YAML, not the whole build.

Choosing a tool

There is no universally best choice, but a few questions settle most cases:

  1. Where does the code live? A team on GitHub or GitLab gets a lot from the built-in option.
  2. Who will operate the CI server? If nobody wants the job, prefer a hosted service.
  3. Are there special constraints, such as air-gapped networks, unusual hardware, compliance rules about data location or very large build farms? These favor self-hosting, often Jenkins.
  4. How much existing investment is there? A working Jenkins with hundreds of jobs has real value; migrate when the pain is greater than the cost, not before.
  5. How much customization do you need? Highly custom workflows lean towards Jenkins; standard ones are cheaper elsewhere.

A stand-in concept mapper

The first stand-in translates a tiny, structured description of a Jenkins pipeline into the vocabulary of the other tools. It is not a real converter (a real one has to understand Groovy and plugins), but it demonstrates how closely the concepts line up.

JS A stand-in that maps Jenkins concepts to other tools

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Seven of the eight concepts map directly. The shared library does not, and that is typical: the pieces that need real design work in a migration are the custom ones.

A stand-in decision scorer

The second stand-in turns the questions above into a weighted score. The numbers are made up for this example; the point is to make your priorities explicit instead of arguing from taste. Change the weights and see how the winner changes.

JS A stand-in weighted decision table

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Same tools, different weights, different winners. If your own list of priorities is honest, the answer usually becomes obvious.

Skills carry over. A team that understands pipelines, caching, secrets and deployment gates as concepts can move between these tools in days; the YAML is the easy part.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which Jenkins concept is closest to a 'job' in GitHub Actions?

    A Jenkins stage groups steps; in Actions the equivalent grouping that runs on a runner is a job.
  2. 2. What does a hosted CI service mainly save you compared with self-hosted Jenkins?

    Hosted services manage the platform for you. You still write the pipelines and still secure your workflows.
  3. 3. When is Jenkins often the better fit?

    Jenkins' flexibility and neutrality help in unusual or restricted environments; for simple projects on GitHub, Actions is usually less work.
  4. 4. What makes a later migration between CI tools easier?

    If the real work is in scripts such as ./ci/build.sh, any CI system can call them and only the YAML wrapper changes.

Summary

  • All major CI tools share the same model: triggers, jobs or stages, runners or agents, secrets, artifacts and results.
  • Jenkins is self-hosted, flexible and neutral; Actions and GitLab CI are integrated with their platform and need less administration.
  • Cost is minutes and runner machines on one side, and servers plus admin time on the other.
  • Translating a Jenkinsfile is mostly mechanical; shared libraries, Groovy logic and plugin features need redesign.
  • Keep logic in repository scripts, migrate gradually, and choose using your actual constraints.

Next, put it all together in Project: CI for a Java Application.