Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 2 of 43 ยท Getting Started

Elasticsearch vs Splunk, Solr, OpenSearch, Algolia and Cassandra

Compare Elasticsearch with Solr, OpenSearch, Splunk, Algolia and Cassandra: architecture, query languages, licensing history and a practical way to choose between them.

"Should we use Elasticsearch?" is rarely a question about Elasticsearch alone. The real question is what job you need done: search a product catalog, analyze logs, power a database, or serve autocomplete from a managed service. These tools overlap in places and differ sharply in others.

This lesson compares Elasticsearch with five neighbors. It sticks to design differences that change slowly. Product features, hosting options, limits and prices change often, so check each vendor's current documentation before you decide. Nothing here is a benchmark.

The short map

Search engines you run

Elasticsearch Lucene, REST and JSON, broad ecosystem.
OpenSearch A fork of Elasticsearch 7.10, same ideas.
Solr Lucene server, mature, very configurable.

All three are built on Apache Lucene.

1 / 2

Elasticsearch and OpenSearch

Elasticsearch is a distributed search and analytics engine built on Apache Lucene. You talk to it over a REST API with JSON, as in Setup and First Requests.

OpenSearch exists because of a licensing change. Elasticsearch and Kibana were released under the Apache 2.0 license until early 2021. Elastic then moved new versions to a dual license: the Server Side Public License (SSPL) and the Elastic License, neither of which the Open Source Initiative recognizes as open source. Amazon, whose managed service was the target of that change, forked the last Apache-licensed version (7.10) and created OpenSearch, which is governed today by the OpenSearch Software Foundation under the Linux Foundation. In 2024, Elastic announced it would add the GNU AGPL as a third license option for the Elasticsearch and Kibana source, so an OSI-approved choice exists again.

What that means in practice:

  • The two share an ancestor, so basic concepts (indexes, shards, mappings, the Query DSL, the bulk API) look the same. Many simple queries run on both.
  • They have diverged since 2021. Newer features differ, the client libraries are separate and no longer interchangeable, and APIs for security, vector search and alerting are not the same. Do not assume that code or tutorials for one work unchanged on the other.
  • The license matters most if you plan to sell a hosted search service built on the code. For an ordinary application that only uses a running cluster, either is usable; read the license text, or ask a lawyer, for your case.

Solr

Apache Solr is also built on Lucene and is older than Elasticsearch. It is a mature search server with deep text features: faceting, highlighting, spell checking, and a very configurable schema (schema.xml or the Schema API). It is a fully open-source Apache project.

Differences you will notice:

  • Solr's classic configuration is more explicit, with XML or schema files, while Elasticsearch leans on JSON APIs and dynamic mappings.
  • Cluster coordination in SolrCloud uses Apache ZooKeeper, whereas Elasticsearch has its own built-in cluster coordination.
  • Elasticsearch grew a large ecosystem for logs, metrics and observability (Kibana, Beats, Logstash). Solr has traditionally been strongest in classic enterprise and site search.

If you already run Solr well, there is usually no urgent reason to move. For a new project, the ecosystem and hiring pool often tip toward Elasticsearch or OpenSearch.

Splunk

Splunk is a commercial platform focused on machine data: logs, events and security analytics. It is not a general-purpose search engine for your application's data. Its strengths are ingestion, dashboards, alerting and its own query language, SPL, where you write pipelines like index=web status=500 | stats count by host.

The Elastic Stack covers similar ground (see Project: Log Analytics). The trade-off is usually this: Splunk is a packaged product with commercial support, priced in its own ways. Elasticsearch gives you components you can run yourself or buy as a managed service, plus the freedom to also use it for product search or vector search. Elasticsearch also has a piped language of its own, ES|QL (see Security, Backups and Operations), which reads somewhat like SPL.

Algolia

Algolia is a hosted search-as-a-service. You send records through an API and use client libraries and UI components to build search boxes with typo tolerance, instant results and ranking rules, without operating any servers. That convenience is the point: little operational work, fast time to a polished search box.

The trade-offs are the flip side. You get less control over analysis, scoring internals and data placement, and your costs scale with usage on the vendor's pricing model. Elasticsearch asks you (or a managed provider) to operate a cluster, but lets you model data, run aggregations over huge datasets and tune relevance in depth. Algolia fits product and content search in an app; Elasticsearch fits when search is one of several analytical or custom needs.

Cassandra

Apache Cassandra is a wide-column database designed for very high write throughput and availability across data centers. It is a system of record: you design tables around the queries you will run, and it answers key-based lookups extremely fast. It does not offer relevance-ranked full-text search or flexible aggregations.

Elasticsearch is not meant to be your primary database either: it is eventually searchable (see Segments and Near-Real-Time Search), is not built for multi-document transactions, and its mappings are expensive to change. Many systems combine the two: Cassandra (or PostgreSQL, MongoDB, and so on) stores the truth, and Elasticsearch holds a searchable copy fed by a pipeline.

Choosing: questions to ask

  1. Is the job full-text search and relevance, log analytics, or storing records? Pick tools built for that job.
  2. Do you want to operate a cluster, or pay someone to? Managed offerings exist for Elasticsearch, OpenSearch and Solr; Algolia and Splunk Cloud are managed by design.
  3. Do license terms matter for what you are building? (They mostly matter for resellers.)
  4. How much control over analysis, scoring and aggregations do you need?
  5. What does your team already know, and what do your cloud provider and tools support?

A decision helper

The stand-in below encodes those questions as a few scored rules. It is a teaching toy that shows how requirements point toward different tools, not an authoritative recommendation.

JS Which tool fits the requirements?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Run it and change the numbers: with different weights, different tools win. The honest answer to "which is best" always starts with "for what".

Same idea, different syntax

The ranking question is the same everywhere; the syntax differs. This stand-in expresses one filter ("errors from host web-1") as an Elasticsearch-style query object and as a Splunk-style pipeline string, and runs both against the same tiny data set.

JS One question, two query styles

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Real SPL and the Query DSL are far richer; the point is that both describe the same selection in different shapes.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Why does OpenSearch exist?

    After Elastic moved to SSPL and the Elastic License in 2021, Amazon forked Elasticsearch 7.10 and Kibana, which became OpenSearch.
  2. 2. Which tool is a database meant to be a system of record rather than a search engine?

    Cassandra stores records and answers key-based queries at scale. It does not rank full-text results the way a search engine does.
  3. 3. Which pairing is correct?

    Splunk uses SPL and targets logs and machine data. Algolia is hosted, SolrCloud commonly uses ZooKeeper, and Cassandra is a wide-column database.
  4. 4. Is it safe to assume Elasticsearch client code works unchanged against OpenSearch today?

    They share an ancestor, but since 2021 they have diverged in features, APIs and client libraries.

Summary

  • Elasticsearch, OpenSearch and Solr are Lucene-based search servers; OpenSearch is a fork of Elasticsearch 7.10 created after the 2021 license change, and Elasticsearch added an AGPL option in 2024.
  • Solr is a mature open-source alternative with a more explicit configuration style and a ZooKeeper-based SolrCloud.
  • Splunk targets machine data with its own language; Algolia is hosted search as a service; Cassandra is a database, not a search engine.
  • Pair a system of record with a searchable copy instead of using one tool for everything.
  • Decide by job, operations model, control needs, license and team skills, and recheck vendor details before committing.

Next: Setup and First Requests, to run Elasticsearch yourself.